Spinning the Games
Trip Start
Jan 30, 2007
1
169
639
Trip End
Dec 31, 2011
Loading Map
Map Options
Show trip route
Hide lines
Beijing,
China
Monday, August 18, 2008
Possibly it has been sucked dry by Western journalists. Or it is under wraps til the CCP give the word.
A lot of media reports are labelling these Games the Fun-less Olympics. They maintain China's security measures have stamped out any fun (and protest).
As this from the Economist and a piece from the Canberra Times outline:
Spontaneous fun is elusive in Beijing these days, writes The Economist's correspondent in China. Tight visa requirements and high security seem to have kept most revellers at bay ...
From ECONOMIST.COM
Juan Antonio Samaranch, a former president of the International Olympic Committee, once said that "without a lively, visible cultural programme that reflects the spirit of the host country, the Olympic games would be incomplete". Finding such a programme in Beijing is a challenge. Spontaneous fun is even more elusive.
Veteran Olympic-games correspondents (these games are my first) speak enthusiastically of street and beach parties at the games in Athens (2004) and Sydney (2000). With perhaps a touch of hyperbole, one tells me that Sydney was taken over by Norwegians with Viking hats and painted faces. I have yet to hear of, let alone encounter, any such revellers in Beijing.
Beijing's Olympic organisers promised the "biggest ever" cultural festival built around the Olympics--the "richest and most diverse in Olympic history," as one official described it. Journalists have been given a "culture guide" containing 100-odd pages of non-sporting events, from traditional Chinese opera to New Orleans jazz.
"Our purpose is to entertain our guests and visitors from all over the world", wrote the chief organiser, Liu Qi, in a foreword.
Sadly, the official guide to cultural events is a minefield of inaccuracies. When I try to buy tickets to some of the foreign musical performances, I am told they have been cancelled or rescheduled.
There are fewer people around to be entertained, anyway. China has tightened visa requirements for foreign visitors in order to keep "undesirables" out. At lunchtime on Sunday, my family and some friends are the only group at a normally popular Thai restaurant on the edge of the city. The manager says business has been getting slower and slower for the last few weeks.
Beijing's bars and nightclubs are doing somewhat better (apart from the ones that have been closed because they are deemed too close to Olympic facilities, or because they are just too seedy). Many of them had expected the police to start enforcing a long-forgotten rule that they close by 2am during the Olympics. So far, at least, the authorities have restrained themselves.
But some bar owners say they expected more customers. China's visa clampdown appears to have kept out the young, boisterous Norwegian-Viking types. And plenty of foreigners already in Beijing seem to have decided to stay at home and watch the Olympics on television, perhaps deterred by security measures on public transport and traffic snarls around Olympic venues. Taxi drivers complain that the bonanza they expected during the games has not materialised.
There is little feel in Beijing that a huge international event is underway. The ubiquitous Olympic banners and posters, and the crowds outside venues, remind people that something big is happening. But many parts of the city are quieter than normal, with factories closed (to avoid pollution), street vendors and beggars less visible (officials have put pressure on migrants from elsewhere to leave), outdoor markets shuttered and some citizens wangling a few days at home.
Tight security is also deterring many people from visiting the Olympic Green in the north of the city, where many of the stadiums are located. This annoys corporate sponsors, who had hoped to attract big crowds to displays they have erected there. The IOC says it has asked the organisers to allow more people into the heavily guarded zone (to add to the festive mood, armoured personnel-carriers have been deployed there).
The top priority of China's leaders is to ensure the games pass without major incidents (terrorism or protests) and that the sporting events are run smoothly. A Chinese friend tells me that he tried to climb a particularly scenic part of the Great Wall just outside Beijing, and was blocked by local vigilantes. They were on the lookout for people who might try to hang subversive banners from the edifice. Mr Liu's professed wish that all of us are "blessed with the best in entertainment" mainly applies, it seems, to what goes on in the stadiums.
The People's Republic of Spin
BY JACQUELIN MAGNAY IN BEIJING
Beijing 2008 is the illusionary Olympic Games. These are the Olympics that claim to have sold out a record 6.8million tickets yet there are empty seats. A sizeable proportion of Beijing's 16million population cram behind barricades to get a glimpse of the spectacular Olympic venues of the Bird's Nest and Water Cube, yet the Olympic Green precinct, which has cost 10 billion yuan ($A1.69billion) and incorporates both venues, is bereft of people and spark.
There have been the fake singer, the fake fireworks, the fake minority kids (they were all Han, and not from the 55 different ethnic groups as portrayed), the fake press freedoms, fake internet access, fake promises. There is a difficulty in ascertaining whether the cheerful welcomes by young volunteers and the exaggerated kowtowing to foreigners are mandated niceties in the national interest or reflect a genuine passion for the Games.
Controversies and non-controversies are airbrushed out. A fatal bus crashes that kills two Chinese nationals and involves Croatian rowers is cleaned up on site within half an hour and never mentioned or written about in the Chinese media in either English-language or Mandarin publications.
A tragic ceremony rehearsal accident to Liu Yan, the country's best classical dancer who has been left a paraplegic is denied, and then watered down as a broken leg for Western media consumption.
Beijing organising committee vice-president Wang Wei and other International Olympic Committee officials repeatedly claim the press is free to report on the Games, yet venue managers, under instruction from the organisers, will not allow reporters to ask topical non-sporting questions of Georgian or Russian athletes. Transcripts of the press conference questions about censorship are themselves heavily censored.
Volunteers in yellow T-shirts and red caps quaintly described as ''cheerleaders'' fill the empty seats. At the Shunyi Olympic rowing and canoe park and Fengtai Sports Centre Softball Field they were bussed and trucked in, wearing shirts emblazoned in English with the words ''Cheering From Beijing Workers''.
They furiously wave flags, blow up noisy sticks and chant in English and Mandarin ''Olympics, Go, Go, Go'' or ''China, Go, Go, Go''.
But expectations of hordes of ordinary Chinese families relaxing and soaking up the Games atmosphere between events by wandering the manicured vast Olympic Green are missing.
So too is spontaneity. One cheerleader said, ''I am here to cheer. I have been practising English.''
Mr Wang said this week, ''We are concerned about the not-full stadiums. Many factors are contributing to this. We are now trying to manage that for the Olympic Green. Yesterday they saw not many people inside.''
Later he noted, ''We are trying to persuade people to respect their rights to watch the Games.''
Sponsors who have injected 20 per cent of the total Games revenue are starting to murmur their dissent.
IOC games executive director Gilbert Felli confirmed this, noting that those sponsors with exhibitions in the Olympic Green precinct who were in the front row were happy, but those further back reported little traffic.
Australian Olympic Committee president John Coates has had a few digs, noting that the organisers have not got the balance between security and atmosphere right.
Central to all of this is control. Chinese officials want to minimise anything that will impact on the image presented to the world through the television audience of four billion but, by doing so, they have exposed themselves to enormous criticism for trying to present a falsely pristine occasion.
There is no doubt the ordinary Chinese people want to see and enjoy the Games, and some of them were lucky to buy the cheap tickets, but many, many thousands more seats have been reserved for the Communist Party's political connections, its military and security. Tickets were distributed through state-run factories for events in lesser demand, but the people have been turned off by the tough security.
Bizarrely, at the Water Cube there are empty seats in the media sections, even though media organisations are heavily restricted in the matter of who may attend by way of a daily ticket allocation and ballot.
On the field of play the competitions have gone smoothly, albeit with a few weather interruptions and some bizarre judging of the double trap shooting, which coincidentally benefited the Chinese bronze medallist.
Chinese attempts to manipulate the messages conveyed around the world through the written press has backfired.
Global headlines, amid the astonishing record feats of Michael Phelps and the bubbling reaction of Australia's female relay swimmers, screech of armoured personnel carriers, human rights, visa restrictions, protest parks, military thuggery, deceptions and trickery. The hostilities between a distrustful organising committee and sceptical media have intensified every day.
Such is the sparring at the daily press conference that it has become a must-watch event on the internal television channel. All this will change in the coming week, of course, with the centre of the Olympic action switching from the 17,000-seat Water Cube to the 91,000-seat Bird's Nest. Athletics is the star attraction of the Olympics and the Games buzz will intensify markedly. Whether this mood shift is rapid and intense enough to turn initial impressions around will be central to the lasting image of these Olympics.
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/news/local/news/general/the-peoples-republic-of-spin/1246073.aspx
