Good but should be a bit better for the price A review of Carter House Inns

As with another one of the reviewers, we found the Carter House to be a very welcome respite in an area where the lodging alternatives are not very appealing. Having stayed at inns in other locals with similar concepts and in the same price zone, however, we noted that the Carter House does aim a bit higher than it hits. The suite we stayed in was cozy and nicely appointed with a comfortable bed but very dark, and there was no light over the two-person jacuzzi in a windowless bathroom, which defeats its intended use for relaxing as opposed to just getting clean. There were two fireplaces, but both had only gas-operated flames (no actual fire) -- probably more safe but they don't throw off any warmth. The restaurant is obviously a big point of emphasis and priced accordingly, but we found it disappointing because one of us (me) is a vegetarian (not vegan) and although they tantalizingingly offer a vegeratarian option for their five-course special dinner menu, the entree (a risotto) our first night was lacking in any flavor. The rest of the food was good (although they forgot to give us bread until after we got our entrees), so we figured it was a fluke and tried again the next night, asking if the cook could provide something different -- they gave me pasta with the exact same stuff on it and also no flavor. This would be exactly what you'd expect in a so-so restaurant but is not acceptable at a place with these aspirations and these prices -- it's too much to pay for a dinner that's obviously an afterthought for the chef. I would recommend that they follow a rule of making every dish tasty enough to satisfy a nonvegetarian foody or not bother with vegetarian options at all -- other upscale inns have tried and succeeeded. Nonetheless, the breakfast is very nice. The staff was friendly. And, again, noone is trying to do anything like this in this area.

Reviewed by
Carter House Inns
358 reviews