Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel and Conference Center

439 Loraine Ave, Put in Bay, Ohio, 43456, United States | Resort
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.
 

How has this resort rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.

Location

This resort, located on 439 Loraine Ave, Put in Bay, is near Perry's Victory & International Peace Memorial, Kayak the Bay, Stonehenge, and Lake Erie Islands Historical Society.
Map this resort

Amenities

       

    Historical Traveler Reviews Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel and Conference Center Put in Bay

    The worst

    from

    Worst place I have ever been. Hotel and rooms are very nice. Staff is unfriendly, there is no bar as stated, and unless you are from ohio they will find a way to screw you. There are other hotels on the island much better and even houses for rent that are perfect for families or groups. The reviews on here that say this hotel is great are from the owner, so don't be fooled.

    Amazing Vacation

    from

    We stayed at PIB resort for Memorial Day weekend and had a very good time. Plenty of people to mingle with at the pool and hot tub, everything was extremely clean. The built in bar was not complete yet, but will be a great edition to next year's trip. We had a guide named Barb, who showed us the ropes for a night (we have never been here before). We thought she was hired by the hotel as a guide, but was actually just a regular to the PIB Island (just goes to show how friendly everyone is). She knew her way around quite well and needless to say Barb now has a spot in our hearts along with PIB Resort. We are looking forward to next year.

    Did they even want us there???

    from

    Rooms are new and fairly nice, but lots of noise from other rooms. Hot tub was great! I did not find the staff to be particularly friendly or welcoming...I felt more like a suspicious intruder than a welcomed guest.

    Fantastic Place to Stay

    from

    This is the most fantastic place on the island to stay bar none. Rooms are spacious and clean. Staff is friendly and curtious. I highly recommend this hotel and it's one of the best in Ohio and definately the best at the Bay as we call it. The Hot Tub, Pool and Swim up bar are out of this world. So if you are going to the Bay and want a wonderful place to stay the Resort is it. Nice that it's only a block off the strip, so you can get away from it if you like and if you've been to the Bay you understand that that's a needed option occasionally. My friends and I throughly enjoyed ourselves. Try it you'll love the resort.

    Awesome Place!!!

    from

    Great people, great times, and a beautiful pool!!!! We had a simply fantastic time and the staff was so very friendly!!! We are hooked! The island is treasure and we will be back!

    A Memorable Weekend

    from

    We love coming to the Bay, but were unprepared to stay overnight and were in dire need of a room for the night. We went to the front desk and 2 lovely girls took care of us and found one room available. I believe one of those girls was Ally. She was very sweet and accomodating to us. The room was not quite ready yet, as it was still early morning, and the former guests had not checked out yet. Ally took my mobile phone number and said she would call me wherever I was on the island to let me know that the cleaning service had completed getting the room ready. I have never experienced such kind and courteous service before! Also, when we returned, I met Kelly at the front desk and her young and very polite son, Dallas. They were so very welcoming, making sure everything was ready for us! All the staff, from what I noticed, were busy, busy, busy...making the PIB Resort a clean and refreshing place to stay! Whether it be vacumming, cleaning rooms, maintaining the pool and the grounds, or just simply opening the door for you....excellent service!!!! You made our unexpected stay a time to remember!! We plan to use the PIB Resort as our home every time we come to the Bay!!!! Thank you all!!!

    Unfriendly Staff

    from

    I stayed in Put-In-Bay last week at the Put-In-Bay Resort and Conference Center and I have to say I was disappointed. Most of the staff didn't smile, never acknowledged us when walking in the lobby. After seeing their supervisor and how she treated employees I can see why. She too, never acknowledged guests, sighed whenever someone asked her a question, and the worst part is she yelled at her staff right in front of guests about people not being on time for her meeting and that she was tired of all the complaints. And like another reviewer said, the pool is RIGHT next to a house and most of the rooms have a view of a little sewage plant. We checked out other hotels and will definitely stay at another place next time.

    What a great place!!

    from

    What can I say? Have stayed @ several places @ the Bay, but was really very happy with the PIB resort! Outstanding service, clean rooms, and the thing that I really look for is customer service. Your staff went way above that. NICE job! I will be staying here when I return to the island in few weeks....Much success to you!

    Excellent vacation stay

    from

    Had a great time at this resort. The staff reached beyond any expectations we had set. We will be returning again next year for a repeat visit. If someone had a bad stay here it was most likely their own fault.

    Don't Waste your Money

    from

    Don't waste your money on this place. Read the previous trip report it it is obvious the people did not pay for the room. Half the rooms overlook a nearby sewage treatment plant, the other half overlook a small pool and jacuzzi area that is in the shade most of the day. The pool area is completely cobbled together with the front yard of a house next door used as part of it. When we called we were lead to believe this was "the" place to stay on Put-in-Bay and it couldn't have been farther from the truth. I was also lead to believe there were no other quality places to stay on the island. There are several and I would advise everyone to look elsewhere. We attempted to get our money back and got into a huge arguement with a guy that we believe was the owner, but not sure. Basically we were told that no refunds would be forthcoming and we had no choice.

    TripAdvisor Reviews Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel and Conference Center Put in Bay

    3.50 of 5 stars Very Good
     

    Travel Blogs from Put in Bay

    On the Road Again

    A travel blog entry by tswine on Aug 27, 2014

    3 comments, 2 photos

    And we're off! Our fifth fall RV adventure has begun...hard to believe. We're excited to be traveling in our new (to us) fifth wheel with plans to visit the national parks in North Dakota, Montana, Washington, Oregon and California. We'll start and end our travels with visits from Zach, Nicole and Isaac which is an added bonus. Katie won't be able to meet us because she just found out ...

    Day One

    A travel blog entry by bisceg on Aug 25, 2014

    1 comment, 6 photos

    ... tired as we approach Cleveland, but we want to get on the west side of the city before we camp so we don't hit the morning rush going into the city. No time to stop at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, but big cities are always cool to drive through.
    We stocked up on some food at Kroger's supermarket and headed to our campsite in ...

    Adrenalin, Religion and a Gentlemen's Club

    A travel blog entry by linleyc on Aug 09, 2014

    15 photos

    ... for example. I have no photos of these, sorry. At cruising speed, even I'm not dumb enough to try to take photos. Besides, by the time I'd read them and savoured their hilarity, I'd blasted past them anyway. These were all in Pennsylvania, and I'm starting to wonder if it's just them that are "special" in this way. I will pay close attention when I hit the road in the next state.

    The first sign to capture my attention was ...

    Great day at Cedar Point Amusement Park in Ohio

    A travel blog entry by thewalshes on Aug 06, 2014

    ... all day to decide to try the Top Thrill Dragster coaster. This ride accellerates to 120 mph within a few seconds and then climbs straight up to ~400' and then straight down and back to the station. There are no appropriate words for this ride that are suitable for a family blog. Suffice to say that this ride is a rush.......

    No pics as it would have been too much of a hassle to bring in a camera to the park.
    ...

    CEDAR POINT - DAY 3!

    A travel blog entry by matthew-thomas on Jul 24, 2014

    Sadly our days at Cedar point are now over! After the usual ride filled morning we went to the water park - Splash City. The slides were quite fun however it was insanely windy, especially at the top of Slides, so Zac and I went back to the Park before dinner whilst Tyler relaxed with a book! We did go into (or ...