Island Bay Resort

Address: 92530 Overseas Highway, Tavernier, Florida, 33070, United States | Resort
 
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.
 

How has this resort rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.

Location

This resort, located on 92530 Overseas Highway, Tavernier, is near Florida Keys Wild Bird Rehabilitation Center, Conch Republic Divers, Pigeon Key, and Key West Water Sports.
Map this resort

Amenities

Photos of Island Bay Resort

    View all photos
         

      Historical Traveler Reviews Island Bay Resort Tavernier

      Great place!

      from

      Excellent service - we had an air conditioning issue when we arrived and they did not hesitate to change our room. Great rooms, very functional with kitchenette. Lockers available for dive gear. I'd stay there again.

      Can't Wait to Return

      from

      Words cannot explain how much I loved this little slice of paradise halfway through the keys. I only booked 3 days in mid May and should have stayed for a week. I booked room 2 (Boats and Birds) and second closest to the water and beach. The rooms and facilities are exactly as described and pictured on the website and the owners are incredibly friendly and helpful. Bed was very comfortable, and the room and bathroom clean and tidy. I did nothing except lay on the sun loungers on a small white sandy beach next to a peaceful bay and watch the amazing sunsets from the dock. I'm loath to recommend the Island Bay in case they don't have any rooms available next time I want to visit!

      Great piece of paradise!

      from

      I had a wonderful and relaxing time at Island Bay Resort. The beach was lovely. The water was clear and clean. We snorkeled, lounged on our floaties, and enjoyed fabulous sunsets!

      Our room was very clean and spacious. It had all the comforts of home.

      The owners are awesome people that would do anything for you! They are very knowledgeable about the area and go above and beyond the call of duty. They take great care of the grounds and are proud of their establishment; and rightfully so!

      I would have given the place an excellent review except one morning I didn't have any hot water in the shower, but about an hour later when my husband showered he had hot water. (?) Also, one of the bathrooms had an odor to it, but we just kept the door closed.

      I will be back in the future! I should tell you all that the place is awful so I don't have a difficult time booking a room in the future, but I'd be lying if I said that were so.

      The place is wonderful!

      Just what we wanted!!

      from

      This place is wonderful! I just returned from a 3 night stay at the Island Bay Resort. I will definitely return. The private beach has plenty of space and was NEVER crowded. It's nice to know that even at full capacity you will never be without a place to relax. We enjoyed snorkeling and kayaking right from the resort. There were lots of little sea creatures around near the shore. The grounds are beautiful and so quiet!! We picked up some simple breakfast foods and enjoyed them every morning on our cottage's deck. The resort looked so nice on their website and it lived up to what I expected (or hoped) it would be. Mike and Carol are great hosts. Everything is clean and comfortable. Instead of staying at a large hotel where you can't find a place to unwind, check out the Island Bay. Another plus is the fact that the rooms mostly accomodate two people, so you aren't likely to find many children running around. We were secluded, yet still just a short drive from everything. Our next visit we will be picking up some seafood from a local market and taking advantage of the grill outside of our cottage.

      Laid back and beautiful

      from

      I had only one night to stay at the Island Bay resort but I really enjoyed the ambiance. It was such a pretty spot-lovely view of the sunset and so peaceful at night. I had a nice clean room, great shower, huge bed-I would reccomend this place without reservation to those who are not into the typical hotels. This was a much more homey and friendly setting.

      A Great Place to Stay....

      from

      All the above reviews are spot on. Impeccably clean, tastefully decorated suites, well cared for grounds and an ideal location to explore the Keys from (conveniently located to Pennekamp State Park, a pleasant one hour drive to the Seven Mile Bridge, close to a Winn Dixie grocery store, and a two minute walk to a gas station/convenience store selling beer/wine). The suggestion above for aquatic/beach shoes is a good one and this should not be taken as a slight against Island Bay as it's a great suggestion and, in my opinion, necessary for ocean swimming anywhere in the keys. Owners Mike and Carol are very friendly and give great advice with respect to other activities (ie. snorkeling) you might want to pursue in the area. Definitely a wonderful and very relaxing place to stay.

      Enjoyed Our Stay

      from

      We had the opportunity to stay at the Island Bay Resort for one night. We had an open night during our vacation and stopped at many places along route 1. We viewed the grounds and rooms of about a dozen hotels and resorts and decided to stay here. We stayed in room #7 which had a bedroom, small living room with futon, dining table and chairs, TV and efficiency kitchen. The room was tastefully decorated and spotless. It's hard to describe the place, it's not overly fancy, but there is great attention to detail. The owners obviously take pride in the place and it shows. The grounds were well groomed and the whole feel of the place was nice. We arrived later in the day, checked in and grabbed our snorkel gear and snorkeled just off the dock. Grassy area around the dock didn't have much to see, but there were tons of fish, a couple of lobsters and what appeared to be a stone crab hanging out under the dock. It was a nice diversion for a little bit. We then grabbed a bottle of wine and sat and watched the sunset at the beach with another couple staying at the resort. This place just makes you want to let your hair down and relax.

      Plan to return

      from

      We spent 3 days at Island Bay Resort in March of 04. Of all of the places we stayed on the Keys, 3 in all, this was our favorite. The cottages are sweet, comfortable and clean. Outside of each cottage is a little deck with a table and chairs and a BBQ grill. Each cottage also has a little tropical garden. The place has a very islandy atmosphere with access to they bay. The boat dock is good for fishing. Beside the boat dock is a little sandy beach for watching the sunsets and swimming. Hosts Carole and Mike are friendly and helpful. I recommend.

      Perfect place to get away from it all

      from

      WOW - this has to be the most beautiful, relaxing place I have ever been to.

      Just check out their web site and its true what you see on the web site is exactly what you get - white sand, hammocks, cute themed cottages with their own bbq grills and decking, fantastic sunsets the list is endless.

      Another bonus is the washer and dryer - not on everyones list of priorities but with kids its a must!

      There really is nothing to do except relax so if you have toddlers invest in a bucket and spade and some beach toys and games, sit back in the hammock and relax! or take a snorkle and admire the beautiful sealife - the water is so clear you can easily see the fish from the simply standing on the small pier. I would recommend that you take along some beach/sea shoes, the sea bed has a fair bit of seaweed, corals and sponges and some quite big crabs - to have something on your feet just makes the whole experience a little more enjoyable but its your own personal choice.

      Tavernier is close to Key Largo, about and hour drive to the 7 Mile Bridge and about 2 hours drive from Key West.

      Whilst here check out Bentleys Restaurant - fantastic Dolphin in the Weeds (not the cute flipper type but the fish type!) and also Robbies Marina to feed the Tarpon.

      Most defo would stay here again - our party consisted of 5 people so we had cottages 9 & 10 which have an adjoining door. Cottage 10 has a big walk in shower which was perfect for bathing children after a day on the beach. 2 x seniors, 1 x 5 year old and 2 x 36 year old - all enjoyed themselves 100% - Perfect.

      Best Kept Secret on the Keys

      from

      I found the Island Bay Resort online when searching for a place to stay on my vacation to the Florida Keys in March 2004. I cannot say enough about how wonderful and relaxing it was. It is a small, quiet place, where there are only 10 cabins, and I had the beach to myself most of the time! What I saw on the website was EXACTLY what I got! The sugar-sand beach, the swaying palms, the hammocks were so entrancing. Each cabin has its own deck, patio furniture, tiki torches and even a charcoal grill. All the rooms are themed and so very clean. The owners, Carol and Mike were very friendly and helpful. The sunsets were gorgeous. If you want a nice relaxing getaway from it all vacation , this is the place to go!

      TripAdvisor Reviews Island Bay Resort Tavernier

      5.00 of 5 stars Outstanding
       

      Travel Blogs from Tavernier

      Sailing away

      A travel blog entry by kathfitzp on Jan 04, 2015

      4 photos

      ... and plantlife, and we each saw a few fishies to make it worthwhile. You could see much more if you dived down, which the boys liked doing. We had an hour at two different spots in the hot sun, so it was a full afternoon and Daniel and Reuben lay on the mesh canopies on the way back and had a little snooze. For tea we had a barbecue on the beach. It's weird not having to worry about things blowing away, or getting too cold when the sun goes ...

      The littlest Hobo

      A travel blog entry by phatchief666 on Sep 06, 2014

      ... the US. I had no idea that the Civil War had such advanced artillery as submarines. There were lots of Civil War facts dotted around the place, such as how evaporated milk was invented during the war to allow soldiers to carry milk on their wagon trails. It was a very similar set up to somewhere like Newhaven fort and it was active until just after WW2 had ended.

      We started our drive back up to the motel to have a rest before dinner. Tonight was a choice between Mrs Macs ...

      Last Days on the Sun

      A travel blog entry by footloose_llr on Feb 22, 2014

      33 photos

      ... like to be organised and there's so much going on today. I managed to get most of the mess tamed before we headed out for breakfast and a little time at the pool, once again of course not managing to get a lounger but at least today I feel like a normal person so the stool wasn't quite so hard to stay upright on! At 10am we have to be up in the Observation Lounge to "mark" the Scavenger Hunt sheets that Ann had passed out at the Meet and Greet on the first ...

      Florida!!!

      A travel blog entry by renee.harbig on Dec 05, 2013

      1 comment, 41 photos

      ... wandering up and down the old streets and alleys..it is a tourist destination and they have done a good job capitalizing on it. It is also the home to Flagler College which is just jaw dropping gorgeous. The architecture and the grounds were very impressive. In the evening we were in for a nice surprise..it was the Light the town Holiday event and It was a very big deal!! They had entertainment all day and when it ...

      Key Largo

      A travel blog entry by tradition on Nov 11, 2013

      3 photos

      ... under warranty, thankfully) and we're back in business. After dinner had a refreshing swim in the pool as we watched the sunset. Suddenly the day wasn't so bad! What a beautiful place. So now we'll adjust our itinerary and try again ...