Historical Traveler Reviews Melvin House Edinburgh
Great hotel/and plenty hot water
a nice quiet area minutes from princes street and all the sites. the bedroom was large and very comfortable we had a standard room the bathroom was filled with good quality shower and shampoo and skincream products, and plenty hot water. breakfast was a joy plenty of ceareals fresh fruit, and porage oats. main courses ranged from lovely omlettes to a full cooked breakfast, it kept us going till well into the afternoon. the staff were very friendly and the service was great. the hotel itselve was better than the pictures showed. I WOULD go back to the MELVIN HOTEL again and again
Great old house atmosphere
We had a great stay in this old georgian house. Beautiful entrance hall and public rooms. Clean rooms and huge breakfast. Loved the little lift. Service and hotel manager are very friendly- despite of other ratings before. They helped us very much with parking possibilities of the car where no fees are charged by the city. I cant understand why people complain about the distance - its no more than 10 minutes to Princess street. In total, its an excellent house in a nice and quiet area.
Staff friendly and water hot
Having read the previous comments, it was with some trepidation that we booked this hotel although it turned out to be a pleasant experience.
The hotel is situated in the West End just a few yards from the Bonham Hotel. There are numerous good restaurants and bars within walking distance as well as an excellent bus service. Our room at the front was spacious, clean and quiet. Contrary to a previous comment the water was hot all day, the towels changed daily and the toiletries replenished. The staff when approached were friendly and helpful at all times.
There was a good choice of hot and cold food at breakfast and we were asked more than once if we required extra toast etc. We didn't frequent the bar, though it looked pleasant, nor did we use the library which looked impressive.
A comment was made previously about the distance to the City. It is a 10-15 min walk to Princes Street but you can jump on a number of buses at the top of the road which will take you to the centre. The bus service is excellent - we paid £2.30pp to travel all day in the City and surrounding area.
We visited Lauriston Castle which is open at the weekend in winter from 2-4. We walked round the grounds, took in the views across the Firth of Forth, strolled through the japanese peace garden and enjoyed a conducted tour of the house which was fascinating and well worth the entrance fee.
If you are looking for a good pub, jump on the bus and go to the Kings Wark in Leith - the mussels are superb!
The two points of this rating are really only for the building and the location. Very rude managers. Service slow and lacking basics i.e. friendliness and hospitality, but hey, after all, it's only a hotel. Considering the price of our stay, one of my worst experiences. It felt as if the managers liked their hotel, only the guests were a burden. With a little effort it could be a great spot.
Melvin House experience
Impressive looking small hotel, friendly welcome. Room basic but adequate for a short stay. There only appeared to be hot water in the mornings for some reason, so showering in the evenings was a bit chilly! A bit far from the main shopping and tourist routes, about 25-30 mins walk at average pace or £4 in a cab. This hotel has the tiniest lift I've ever seen, so if you aren't good in confined spaces and happen to be roomed on the fourth floor, be prepared for a hike up the stairs! Plenty of choice for breakfast, a bit slow to serve but good food when it came. Shame there is no evening restaurant service, some other options nearby about 10 mins walk, but not ideal if you have children with you.
Considering the price paid, £95per night, for a 3 night stay, this was hardly good value. The housekeeping was quite terrible (no clean towels), and the manner of the reception staff quite rude. Locationwise, ok but a bit of a walk into the main town area. Overall, not one I would reccommend.
Great little traditional hotel in the centre of Edinburgh!
I stayed at Melvin House for a long weekend in February 2005. Our room was at the back of the (impressive) building, and had fantastic far-reaching views towards Dean village and beyond. We had a Master room which was HUGE, nicely decorated in a traditional style, and very clean and comfortable. Location couldn't be better - only 5min walk to Princes Street but away from the hustle and bustle. Breakfast was very good with plenty of choice, and service excellent. Overall a great little traditional hotel in the centre of Edinburgh - highly recommended!
I stayed at this hotel for 2 nights in February - and can highly recommend it! It is only a 5/10 minute walk to Princes Street (the main shopping street), and from here the other attractions are all easily accessible. We booked a standard double room which was a very good size, and had superb views of the castle. Everything in the hotel was very clean and well maintained, and the staff were very friendly and helpful! The breakfast was great, loads of choice. including cereal, fruit, cooked breakfast, muffins, cheese, ham, toast, croissants etc etc! I have recommended this hotel to everyone who wants to visit Edinburgh and will definitely be using it again myself! It offers exceptional value for money in a great location, you are just a 5 minute walk from some great restaurants.
Superior Guest House Hotel
Arrived in Edinburgh on June 23 without reservations. Stopped by a booking agency and found a room available at the Melvin Guest House Hotel for 3 nights. Hotel manager offered a reduced rate (80 GBP/night) for the hotel's smallest room. Reluctant but desperate, so booked it for 3 nights.
Neighborhood is quite and charming but a 30-minute walk to the city center. Victorian style townhome converted to a classy hotel. Manager is very friendly and honest. Smallest room in the house is plenty big for two light-packing adults. The ensuite bathroom is almost as big as the "small" room. Charming furniture and décor. Good quality bed linens and towels. View of the village in the valley with stream running through.
Room rate includes a breakfast that will set you until late in the afternoon. Includes a cold buffet of fruit, cereals, and yogurt; Scottish porridge; choice of 4 hot breakfasts (one choice is full Scottish breakfast); and juice, coffee, or tea. All served by friendly waitresses.
Enjoyed the hotel and staff so much that we stayed on an extra 3 nights!
Great traditional townhouse property
My golf tour company has been using Melvin House for a few years. It is a traditional townhouse hotel in one of the few quiet locations in Edinburgh, yet only a few minutes walk from Princes Street. The rooms are large and in excellent condition. The hotel has a comfortable bar and serves a great traditional breakfast. There is no restaurant for other meals but it is just a short distance to a variety of great restaurants.The only downside can be the parking - it is on street and there are parking meters that operate during the day for 6 days a week, or you can use the NCP parking nearby.
TripAdvisor Reviews Melvin House Edinburgh
Travel Blogs from Edinburgh
... this but luckily it worked out in my favor. It was only 2pm and a short bus ride to the Royal Botanic Gardens of Edinburgh. Within 10 minutes I was at the east gate and walked through the entrance into the gardens. It was absolutely stunning – trees turning fall colors, grass glistening with dew, water rippling from various ponds. I just couldn’t get enough! The gardens were perfectly landscaped and were a treat for the eye. When I go out into nature, I prefer ...
... to eat there are so many places to choose from no matter what your budget. If you are looking for more up market places I suggest George Street where the majority of designer shops are along with some of the most lovely (yet pricey) restraunts are. Tiger Lily, The Dome, Gustos, Cafe Rouge and Cafe Aduluca are probably my favorites. But being a student I often head down to the Grassmarket which is a lovely area of Edinburgh where there ...
... quickly realized that she was claustrophobic but managed to stay clam under we reached some fresh air again. We were told stories about the land, about the people, about witches and spirits and living back in those times….very interesting and worth the 2 hours.
Travelling definitely takes it out of you, by 9.30 we were buggered and decided to go back for a nap (as the sun was still as it was at midday) for an hr then venture on for a night ...
... are full of young lambs who would have no road sense. We headed north and over the border into Scotland to Gretna Green, well known for marrying run away couples and most possibly underage. Back down across the border again and on to see Hadrian's Wall. This is a Roman relic and the oldest Roman structure still standing in England. Back across the border again and on to Melrose Abbey. This relic was once occupied by an order of Monks, but ...
... had a dog, named Bobby, would he owned only 2 years before the owner passed away. He was buried in this cemetery, and everyday for 14 years Bobby laid on his grave. He only left at 1pm (when the cannon's fire from the castle) to go to a neighboring restaurant to get lunch. After 14 years, he passed and is buried around the corner from the cemetery, since animals are not allowed to be buried in the cemetery itself. However, there is a headstone that reads "Let his Loyalty and ...