How has this hotel rated in the past?
TravelPod Member ReviewsWhite Elephant Nantucket
I stayed in the White Elephant with a couple of friends over the Easter weekend. It was quite an impromptu visit, and we only booked our room about two weeks prior. We had to make an amendment before we arrived, adding another person to stay in our room, and not only were the staff very helpful and accommodating, but they also upgraded us to a room with a harbour view, which we were to discover was absolutely beautiful.
We headed to this hotel straight from arriving in Nantucket on the ferry, and even though we were too early to get into our room, the staff at check in were very friendly, and helped us with checking in and making a dinner reservation for the night.
We were very lucky with the weather on our weekend in Nantucket, so we made the most of the beautiful Easter Saturday afternoon by relaxing on the lawn outside our room, overlooking the harbour. Our room opened out onto the lawn, and there were a number of sun loungers for use. The room service we ordered was prompt and exactly what we wanted, and all of the staff members we came across were wonderful.
Our evening meal was spent in the restaurant
Before heading back to the mainland, on Sunday we had a lovely brunch, again in the restaurant.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TravelPod member and not of TravelPod.com.
Historical Traveler Reviews White Elephant Nantucket
The White Elephant is no White Elephant!
The White Elephant was a welcome surprise based on my past experiences staying on Nantucket. The hotel is ideally located, a few minutes walk from town and Jetties beach, waterfront with a great view of the lighthouse and the Harbor. Although I was there off season, there are wonderful places to walk and relax on the water.
A complementary van meets all ferries so we sent our luggage along and opted to stroll over to the hotel at our leisure. Our room was upgraded (we paid $200 per night and I know the suite was priced at $275 as I had declined to book it.) We had a fully renovated suite with a terrace overlooking the ocean, a gas fireplace and large sitting room. Because they asked when I made the reservation, a bottle of champagne and box of chocolates met us in the room for my friend's birthday, again complementary. The room was luxurious, with elegant nantucket style.
The service was fine. They offered to drive us to our dinner reservation, arranged a tour of the island for my friend the following day, and also recommended restaurants. There is a continental breakfast included and plentiful copies of the Globe and NYTimes in the library.
After staying in many charming but decrepit places on the island, the White Elephant is an optimal mix of charm and modernity. I would highly recommend it off season, not sure if I would pay $600 plus anywhere in the summer. If you ever have a chance to see Nantucket lit up for Christmas, take it!
Great place to enjoy the Island of Paradise!
Highly recommend the White Elephant. The service staff was exceptional and so friendly. The food and rooms exceeded my expectations. We will be back next year.
True Luxury in Nantucket
The room was clean and beautifully decorated. The staff could not have been more helpful. The restaurant is top quality. What more could you ask?
Lovely but expensive
Unbelievably nice with harbor view but we stayed only one night and it cost $700
You're not paying for service, that's for sure
I stayed in two rooms here, one with a "harbor view" through two small windows and the other a suite with grease spots and primitive drawings (I suspect by a five year old with a marker) all over the couch. I covered it with a blanket.
The service here can be remarkably bad. They hire young foreign students, many of whom have no idea what they're doing. A bellhop watched as I trudged toward the hotel with my luggage, then followed me to my room hoping for a tip. A surly reservations clerk at the front desk never once cracked a smile the entire week I was there.
It's a shame really. This hotel is in a great location and the food in the restaurant is outstanding (the filet mignon was exceptional). The restaurant staff is also very friendly.
At these prices, I'll stay somewhere else in the future and simply have dinner here.
Nantucket in the off season is simply lovely and the same can be said for the White Elephant Hotel. Rooms are very tasteful -- beautiful leather headboards and linens and the bathroom is a classic neutral tone. Public spaces are meticulously maintained and the staff helpful. Only suggestion we have is to have WIFI for guests.
A pretty enough place, and clean, but just-average, overpriced food and poor service dimmed our time there. We had booked a particular cottage, for a special occassion, and we were assigned it when we checked in. But it wasn't ready yet, so we took a walk around town--and returned to find it had been given to someone else. A woman at the front desk insisted we must have been mistaken -- little realizing we had just overheard her scream loudly at someone in the back room for giving it away. The cottage we we're given instead just wasn't as nice, by a long shot, but it was more the staff's ill-humour --the hotel was fully booked and everyone from the gardener to the restaurant manager seemed stressed-out and grouchy -- that made us not really interested in returning. This is priced like a Ritz, and run a bit more like a Howard Johnsons.
We spent our honeymoon at the White Elephant. For 20 years we stayed in the cottages, main building and new building...Miss the pool. It was
so nice being at the pool and seeing the harbor. Diner was dress code (long dresses and suits) I think the lounge was called the shell lounge (or
pretty close) and we spent our evenings in there. We also took our children there... We are now retired and when we are in Nantucket we make sure to have a drink in the White Elephant lounge. The Hotel is so full of life memories. Thank you Elephant.
My husband and I had selected the White Elephant for our anniversary- Nantucket had always been one of the places we had wanted to visit but never had gotten around to. Although we had arrived during an atypical May Nor'easter (complete with 15 foot swells which necessitated taking the "freight boat" over if we were going to arrive that day) the arrival at the hotel was a very pleasant surprise. Gracious surroundings, very pleasant and accomodating staff at the front desk and our harborfront room was lovely with a fireplace and well appointed. Each evening during the turndown service a soft jazz station is turned on making your room a wonderful haven to return to. Food was wonderful (including the extensive buffet breakfast with cooked to order omlets). Every afternoon there is a lovely Port and Cheese reception in the library which can be enjoyed outdoors near the water.
The location is excellent offering an easy walk into town. In general, one gets the impression that the staff is well trained and truly wants to please-
Very nice experience, highly recommended!
Perfect honeymoon spot
we entered the lounge greeted by a wonderful pianist who flawlessly performed my favorites by Beethoven. after a cocktail at the bar,we were seated outside with a view of paul newman's boat. nice boat. dinner and wine were spectacular. the waiters and waitresses were the most accomodating servers i have ever had bar none. the service after the meal was also beyond reproach. they brought out a shaw and heated lamp-post type thing (sorry for the poor description,never saw something like that before) for my new wife,who had been chilled by the nighttime ocean air. if i could afford it , i would eat there every day.
TripAdvisor Reviews White Elephant Nantucket
Travel Blogs from Nantucket
We started the day on the quintessential beach called Dionis. Sandy dunes and gentle surf made for hours of fun. Olivia took a leap in her swimming skill and developed an honorable dog paddle. In the evening, we celebrated our 15th anniversary with our kids starting with happy hour and a memorable meal at the Straight Wharf. These 15 years of marriage have been infused with adventure and ...
... fast...it always does when you are having a wonderful time...it was time to say goodbye (the sad part) and start planning the next family get-together (the joyous part)...my angel and I will return to Nantucket in September, and I am sure the weather would be as gorgeous, and the island as charming, and we would have a great ...
Here at last! Nantucket has always been a figment of my imagination. A remote and legendary New England island thirty miles from anything. What would it be like? Jesse has been seriously wondering if this vacation will be any fun at all. He is worried. We rented bikes at the island bike rental and rode to the lovely Surfside beach where the kids enjoyed ...
Our vacation finally begins! The ride through Massachusetts was easy and lovely. Leaving on a Sunday and going against traffic didn't hurt either. We chose Nantucket so that we could explore a new place and have a true summer holiday with the family. We booked the vehicle ...
... a fun venue for family to gather, eat, drink, and generally be merry.
We walked the cobblestone streets, window shopped, looked at the marina and found a dog that had escaped from its owner - which we returned. Later in the day, we walked to Slip 14 for a fabulous open bar and wonderful meal - the rehearsal dinner.