How has this hotel rated in the past?
- Drycleaning onsite
- Meeting rooms/conference facilities
- Minbar in room
- Room service
- Breakfast Available
Historical Traveler Reviews The Mansfield New York City
Booked this through expedia as part of a package and then read the reviews (wrong order i think and i would advise reading the reviews first!). some of the reviews said it was excellent and some said not so good and i would say it honestly falls somewhere in between. Location is excellent. Between 5th and 6th Avenue and about 5 minutes from Times Square and the subway to other parts of the city. Rooms are small but not as miniscule as some of the reviews made out (but Americans may be used to more spacious accomodation). Didn't try out the M bar but it certainly looked classy. All the reviews talked about the 24 hour cappucino machine but you should also know there's tea too! Staff were friendly and courteous but there's no room service to speak of (and nothing in your room to indicate what services if any-- except laundry--that the hotel would provide). One small gripe about service was the fact that we mentioned 3 times about poor TV reception (TV viewing was not high on our list of things to do in NYC so it didn't matter that much except early morning and late night) and were promised attention that never ever came.All in all a clean, smart and perfectly acceptable hotel and a great central location to return to every evening and polite staff. We felt that we had a good experience staying at the hotel but part of us kept thinking that perhaps we could have got a better experience staying elsewhere on a similar budget...but who really knows.
I don't know why everyone raves about the location: not close to The Park, not close to the best shopping (Soho & Village), not close to business (Wall Street). But my stay here was very happy. Try to get the penthouse suite, if possible. Two floors of sunlight and comfort; two tvs, two full bathrooms... Would definitely come again!
Would definitely go back to the Mansfield!
We loved this elegant, yet unpretencious, boutique hotel in a great location in midtown. The staff is excellent, the rooms (small) but beautiful with desirable amenities. Loved the coffee/tea bar in the lobby. Check the hotel's website for the best rates I could find, even compared to expedia and travelocity.
Unexceptional, but saved by location and sense of relaxed modern elegance
Interesting fusion of Beaux Arts and contemporary style marks this boutique hotel as noteworthy--restoration manages to sensitively reflect the history of the building. The location is exceptional for both the NYC first-timer and familiar mid-town acolyte, with the Oak Room at the Algonquin a nice counterpoint reached by a one-minute stroll. Standard rooms easily fall into the category of small, even for NYC, but are immaculately maintained and furnished with luxuries like Frette linen and Aveda bathroom products. Another nice feature is the on-tap Cappuccino, Americano et al. available from the reading room on the lobby level. What is less impressive is the absence of genuine room service and intimacy typically associated with boutique hotels. Staff are reasonably attentive, but frequently seem pre-occupied. Hence on balance you?d fare better at the Algonquin Hotel if seeking a substantive feel of permanence that manages to echo halcyon days in the City, whereas the Warwick Hotel would fulfil the needs of those who need a full-service hotel that combines generously sized rooms without a corporate feel. Both alternatives are similarly priced to the Mansfield Hotel, but represent more satisfying examples of this category of hotel.
Why the fuss?
The reviews were in and they were wrong....My room brought me closer to New York in all the worst ways...no soundproofing so every street noise above a whisper wafted through my window--and the plumbing is so audible that when someone flushed I could not hear the tv, really. I booked the larger room..larger to a Lilliputian. It was almost impossible to take a shower without flooding the bathroom. The service matched the rest of the experience..my phone buzzed so loud I had to cancel a conference call..was told it would be fixed and had to call three times to make that happen asked three times for a mending kit...no taxis On the plus side...the location is good. It is actually in the city.
We don't stay anywhere else.
*I miss the breakfast.
Loved the Mansfield Hotel
We went to NYC for the Thanksgiving Day parade and a broadway show (Frankie & Johnnie in the Clair de Lune).
The hotel is on west 44th street, a couple of blocks from Times Square and on the fringes of the Broadway Theatre district. When we checked in, the Mansfield Hotel offered us complimentary glasses of champaign.
The room was tiny but more than adequate considering that we got the room for only $120/night through priceline.
The bar was closed because of some problems transferring the
liquor licence. Continental breakfast was served for $10, which is what they charged to bring a large pot of coffee to our room. However, there was free complimentary coffee (an expresso machine) in the reading room off the lobby. The staff was extremely friendly!
A Midtown Treat
A wonderful location at an outstanding price (Expeedia gets you one night free). W. 44th right off of 5th is a great place to be, close to everything, but quiet even in midday. The two blocks to Times Square are full of interesting things (the whimisical facade of the landlocked home of the NY Yacht Club is worth a trip down 44th alone) and first rate restaurants. Be sure to get a suite. The rooms are small (as is the whole building) but the suite is a great value and exceptionally comfortable. The M Bar is terrific and the service friendly and welcoming... their Manhattan is as good as any you will ever get in its namesake city. The 24 hour espresso machine doesn't sound like that much of an amenity, but is a real treat when you get in late from a night on the town. Only downsides... airshaft views from the suites and no in-room movies... but if you'd wanted the Sheraton you'd have gone their anyway. A special place for people who enjoy and understand Manhattan.
Don't make this your first choice
I stay in NYC every few weeks on business and part of the pleasure is booking a different hotel each time through the online travel web sites. I read some great things about the Mansfield hotel. Unfortunately, they over-rated this- at best- three star hotel.
Probably the smallest room I have ever stayed in. The room reminded me of Ian schrager's Hotels, which are also very small. However at the Hudson, Paramount, Royalton, Etc you give up space for being at a very cool spot. The fixtures were definitely not as cool as the ornate italian paneling at the Hudson. And the room which was supposedly re-done seems rund down.
The lone advantage of this hotel is its central location, if you are in NYC for one night you may be able to take the smallness, otherwise I suggest trying elsewhere....
The Mansfield Hotel
I stayed 3 nights at the Mansfield in May 2002, after reserving a package through expedia.com without knowing anything about the hotel. What a delightful stay!! The room was small-small, but then I'm from Texas and I understand all rooms in Manahattan are small. But the quiet, and eminities were great--down pillows, down comforter and quaintly renovated bathroom with a modern touch was a great oasis after days of combing Manhattan. The staff was helpful, professional and tolerant of this rube. If you book a package deal, don't expect the penthouse suite, but you will not be disappointed. I am a single woman and felt very safe. I was also tickled to get a knock on my door each evening from a staff member with chocolates. One morning I returned from breakfast to find a rose on the bedstand. You can't beat the ambience--I could have mistaken myself to be in Europe--or the feeling of luxury.
TripAdvisor Reviews The Mansfield New York City
Travel Blogs from New York City
... br> photographs, so we joined them in doing so. The humidity is high today and the train was stifling. We then had a walk from 86th street to 82nd Street and sheltered under the shop verandahs from the sun. The museum cost $25 per person plus another $7.00 for an audio guide. By the next time we come, we will be able to use our phones with headphones for free to hear about the same pictures – there is ...
... uphill battle!) - but did manage to interview Luke as a compromise (at the end of the video, attached).
Day 2 highlights: Museum of Natural History; Central Park; Mom & Mia shopping at H&M - Mia in her element with new jacket!; finishing off at hotel bar (after kids asleep) sipping Mohitos and eating tapas.. ...
Basically a full day of travelling which was the most stressful thing I have ever encountered - and I have a degree! 6 hour flight to NYC was fine, they had the 10th season of friends on the flight so managed to finish it .. Woohoo! But the wait at border control was horrible! Two hours standing in a hot & stuffy queue to then drive 2 hours on the other side of the road in the middle of the night with no food in your belly since lunch and no sleep since 9 am the following ...
... getting on the boat line. This takes ages. We finally board the boat and enjoy the quick trip out to Liberty Island. The view of the city landscape as the boat moves away from Manhattan is awesome.
We get to Liberty Island and ask about getting up to the crown. Unfortunately we are told that you had to prebook the tickets online and the usual wait is three months. So we are stuck with walking around the grounds only. After lunch where I was enticed by the crinkle fries, we ...
... and could beat him up. After that he kept apologising and telling me how pretty I was. What a wally!!!!!!!!!!! I did get home safe and sound and didn’t report him in the end as ultimately he knows where I live and I don’t want to feel nervous walking around. However, out here if you do report an illegal taxi they lose their car and get a $10k fine... so tempting!!! Since that event I keep seeing signs everywhere saying ...