Sidney James Mountain Lodge

Address: 610 Historic Nature Trail, Gatlinburg, Tennessee, 37738, United States | 3 star hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.


This 3 star hotel, located on 610 Historic Nature Trail, Gatlinburg, is near Ober Gatlinburg Ski Resort & Amusement Park, Smoky Mountain Brewery, Star Cars Museum, and Gregory Bald via Gregory ridge.
Map this hotel



    Historical Traveler Reviews Sidney James Mountain Lodge Gatlinburg

    Deceived by brochure


    We only lasted thirty minutes in our dark, dirty, and out-dated room.

    Our room looked nothing like the ones in the brochure. There were black handprints on doors, and sticky stuff on light switch I went to use. We ate the cost of that night and left immediately and went somewhere else. The so-called balconies were a joke.

    A great place to stay


    We arrived at the Sidney James Mountain Lodge on 7/13/03 and stayed for 6 days - loved every minute of it. The desk staff and staff in the poolside cafe were exceptionally nice and accomodating. Inside and outside pools were very clean without the usual heavy chlorine pools that hotel pools tend to have. We had breakfast nearly every day in the poolside cafe which was quick with good food and very reasonable prices. My son loved playing in the creek! We will definitely be back!

    Hated It


    This was the worst place I have ever stayed in. You could call it a Roach Motel or better yet a Spider motel. We even asked for our money back right after we saw the room and they REFUSED to give us our money back.

    What a dump!


    The internet pictures made the Sidney James look very attractive when in fact the place is run down and filthy. I was so disappointed. They have a three-day cancellation notice and we were only staying 3 nights so we were stuck. I would not walk on the carpet after my shower because the carpet was sooooo dirty. With a lot of TLC the Sidney James could be nice but they obviously don't care about the upkeep. What a shame!

    Loved it!


    We recently stayed two nights at Sidney James and we loved it! Comfortable and convenient and the staff was VERY friendly and helpful. We definitely hope to go back again!

    Great cottages and rooms!


    We have stayed at the Sidney James 3 years in a row now, most recently in March of 2003. We have stayed in regular rooms, and rented a 3-bedroom cottage. The rooms are clean, the staff is friendly and courteous, and the rates are very reasonable. This appears to be a very family-friendly place to stay and is within easy walking distance to downtown. We will be back again next year!

    Not so great


    Entire facility is a little out of date. Was disappointed with the balcony size, its shallow depth prevented chairs. The HVAC unit mounted over the door had bare wires hanging out. And the fireplace wasn't operable. Overall experience was okay, but next time we'll look elsewhere. Townsend.

    Great place to stay!


    This hotel is AMAZING!

    I highly recommend a small jaccuzzi suite...very nice for a low price....great staff friendly service...I have always and will continue still to stay at this hotel.

    Great place to stay


    The people have always been very professional. The rooms are wonderful.....get a jacuzzi suite overlooking the creek if you can. I have always stayed here and will continue to do so into the future.

    Treated very rude and unprofessionally


    we had reservations there 2 weeks ago on fri & sat night, we did not know until we checked in the room that was for "handicap". needless to say, with the way the room was adapted for such a person, we were quite inconvienced by it. upon calling the from desk to register several complaints, having to hold the shower head in your hand while showering, when heat was turned on there was an offensive odor, the smoke went off, the man who took the call was very rude and hung up on me. when we checked out a day early and went into the office to collect our refund for one night, no one in the office offered an apology, as a matter of fact they said nothing. we will never visit this hotel nor recommend it to anyone. sincerely, mitzi clayton

    TripAdvisor Reviews Sidney James Mountain Lodge Gatlinburg

    3.00 of 5 stars Good

    Travel Blogs from Gatlinburg

    "On Our Way Rejoicing"

    A travel blog entry by ingram.mho1 on Oct 08, 2015

    1 comment, 12 photos

    ... floods and devastation. A lot has happened while we've been away but we have been proud of the way our state has rebounded and are moving forward.

    We're excited to be getting home tomorrow. We’ve been very fortunate through all our travels and have enjoyed sharing our adventures with our friends and family. We’re glad I wrote the blog because it’s already hard to remember some of the names of places we’ve been!


    The adventure begins

    A travel blog entry by sdaves on Sep 29, 2015

    ... the 25th year of the German reunification (1989). They were expecting thousands of people in Frankfurt and we actually ( on Saturday night) watched the major event on the TV. Dinner was at a very small local eatery where we had pork and potatoes ( of course) and wine. We sat at long wooden table with style. A neighborhood German place full of locals and fun to experience. We returned "home" and settled down for the night.

    Las Vegas of Tennessee

    A travel blog entry by judencharlie on Sep 09, 2015

    7 photos

    ... and things bigger than Ben Hur. And what do we notice, but there are hordes of people on the side of the road with deck chairs set up lining the streets. In parking lot after parking It are hordes upon hordes of classic cars. OK we get it, there must be a classic car show of sorts in town and given everyone is sitting in their chairs on each side of their main , there must be a parade. Nope! As we subsequently find,out, they are ...

    Aug 21-23rd - Maryville TN

    A travel blog entry by mazk on Aug 21, 2015

    12 photos

    ... the GPS told us there was a 26 minute slow down on our
    travel route and it was right. An extra half hour was spent in a
    couple of thousand car traffic jam due to a small road accident.
    We've been very blessed to have barely any problems with traffic or
    at least unexpected traffic. We knew driving around major cities that
    there would be some level of congestion. But apart from this hold up,
    there has been hardly anything else so that has been ...

    Aug 18th - 20th - Great Smoky Mountains

    A travel blog entry by mazk on Aug 18, 2015

    13 photos

    ... sup>th – day 108

    We relaxed for the day at Yogi
    campground. In the morning Kaitlin bought and coloured a t-shirt.
    $8.50 for an hours entertainment and a souvenir. Good deal. We
    almost went on a walk. Ben headed out beforehand to follow the sign
    we had seen for Mingo Falls. It said 2 miles which seemed doable but
    we have had experience walking with our children many times on this
    trip and wanted to now what the ...