New York Inn
How has this hotel rated in the past?
Historical Traveler Reviews New York Inn New York City
Not fit for human habitation!!!
This hotel goes from bad to worse - first impressions are the porn shop downstairs and the filthy reception area. The rooms are tiny, dirty and in terrible repair but the worst part is the other guests - the vermin!!! DO NOT STAY HERE!
What I expected
The hotel is about what I expected, considering the price. $85 in New York is NOTHING. Yes, the hotel was run down and could have used a bit more upkeep (actually, I ran out to the drugstore and got a few cleaning supplies), but there was nothing really wrong with it. It's just what it is. The 'remodeling' is just an excuse to have a run-down hotel- or did you think you were staying at 4 star for that price?
A Big Mistake Too Late
I wish I had gone to this site first to read the comments before booking (and staying) here. Everything you see and read is absolutely true. I expected and accepted a small room. But the broken dresser, lamps, shower curtain, blinds and sink made for unsafe surroundings.
The bags of garbage piled high in the hallways each night no doubt provided the unsanitary surroundings. The condom wrappers still in the room upon check-in and in the kleenex container (which remained empty and uncleaned during my stay) added to the overall dirtyness. The place is no doubt a leftover of the seedy times of 8th Ave and Times Square.
Even the renovations being down can't save this place. Avoid at all costs.
Don't even contemplate it
My friend and I booked this mainly due to good price and location, however once arriving we stayed for about 5 mins and then left to find somewhere else (considering we arrived at 10.00pm, one only has to imagine how awful it was!) the whole place was run down - the stair case felt like it was about to collapse at any time. Our room was down some dark corridor (room number had disappeared) and once entering, our attention was drawn to the ceiling panels that were missing (the others we stained by what looked to be a previous leak). we asked for 2 double beds, we got 1 double and a single (which moved when you sat on it).
behind the beds was all sorts of dirt and dead bugs. the bathroom - large enough for one (just), this too had stained and missing or dislodged ceiling tiles. the shower curtain was filthy and was the shower. we didnt dare lift up the toilet seat. after walking around new york for a while we found the comfort inn and happily paid more. I'm not exaggerating in the least and would suggest to anyone to never go near this place.
My boyfriend from out of town made reservations at this place and I got their before he arrived. This place was so decrepit and scary. The room was the size of a large closet. The stairs leading to the room were dirty and in disrepair. The entire place had a funny smell. When I went to cancel the reservation at the front desk, the clerk got very upset and said this wasn't possible & that our credit card would be charged.
Thankfully my boyfriend knows his rights & prevented this from happening. Whatever you do DO NOT stay at the New York Inn.
We reserved a room from here on orbitz, where they said in the description that it was a nice place, being "renovated" but good, and the picture didn't look to bad, with price and loation how could you beat it? well as we ran down the street, we almost missed the hole in the wall, which is the new york inn. the loby full of old news papers, and smelling of subway (hotel is connected to a subway, not by choice) the man at the desk seemed nice. the room was another story, the bed covers had some "unknown" substance on it, the bathroom was about the size of a small closet, with mildew overtaking the tile and a hanger holding up the shower rod. we knew we could only stay there for one night at the most, but as we sat on the bed and noticed a rat move quickly from under the bed, we packed our bags and left in a hurry, the man at the front desk could only say "did you leave food out" to make us feel better about this problem, so we ran to the best western down the street where we got a hotel for 10 dollars cheeper! dont stay here!!!!!
staff very nice.have stayed there 4 times since last year. prices are a bit high but they always welcome me and my girlfriend.
My friend and I booked the hotel online through CitlyBase..... when we got there we were scared! The place was being "renovated" and there were sand bags in the front entrance. We booked a double bed, but the man at the desk kindly told us we could have 2 twins... which we accepted. The room was awful.... there were hairs in the bed and our bathroom had no toilet paper and no towels... you wouldn't want to step foot in there with fear that you would get a fungal infection... and I'm not exaggerating..... We were nervous about asking for reimbursement, there was NO way we were staying there. We told the guy at the front desk that our room was unsatisfactory... he got the maid to clean it and to change the sheets.... we still hadn't planned on staying... we phoned CityBase from the payphone and they told me it was okay not to stay there and refunded my money...... hopefully by the end of the month my VISA will be reimbursed. We went down the street to the Howard Johnson and got a king size bed and a NICE bathroom for $10 more a night.... my advice is definitly stick with the chains... the picture they show of the room online of the New York Inn is deceiving.... two young women definitly did not feel safe there!
Stayed here might be a misleading term
I initially booked this hotel based on price and location, but once I got there, I was looking for another hotel within an hour. The room was dark and dingy, with a tiny bathroom and shower that needed some serious scrubbing. Dissatified with this room, they showed me another that was even worse--two of the three beds had no bedspreads and there was an army of little bugs in the shower.
Thanks to the Best Western President on 48th St for having an available room. It blew my budget, but it was immaculate.
Dirty...run down...scary.....don't bother. Run, don't walk someplace else.
TripAdvisor Reviews New York Inn New York City
Travel Blogs from New York City
I was a bit late getting on my New York bus in the end, which was ridiculous as I had arrived at the station a whole four hours ahead of my departure time. I was distracted by two police officers boarding the New York-bound Greyhound bus- due to leave 30 minutes before my New York-bound Megabus- to apprehend a New Jersey-type business man. They proceeded to escort him off the bus and then the three of them had some sort of altercation on the concourse. The officers (one Black, ...
... now in charge of locating restaurants.
After filling our bellies we went to Madam Tussauds, for no other reason that it contained a Marvel 4D experience. Looking around the figures was actually good fun though, as the rather large amount of photos indicates. Standing next to a was Jon Bon Jovi is probably the closest I’ll get to standing next to the real thing, but a girl can dream! The 4D ride ...
... night with celebratory drinks at Jimmy’s rooftop which we had not been to before. Like any rooftop out here it had great views of the Manhattan skyline. It was so nice to all be together again. So much had changed since the summer away day we had as a team in Hoboken what with two engagements, Nat and Greg expecting a baby in a month and Sajni having just joined the team to replace Thomas and Rich (as Thomas says it's ...
After arriving in style at the airport (via 'POD' no less!) and seeing Greenland on the way (sorry, obligatory plane photo!) we arrived in New York.
It is an epic place and with so much to do, tours to take, places to visit, we decided to do our own tour. As we are geeky by nature we decided to base our travels on two things. Food and video game locations.
What surprised us is how easy it is to walk ...
... controlling the amount of people that could cross the road.
We decide to walk back to our hotel, but it’s quite a distance. We walk down Broadway Street; yep a bit posh I think but hang on it gets better. Geoff says that we are going to look for handbags as we go along. We go into Bloomingdales, Prada, Zara and other posh sounding places, and I come out with nothing. Geoff said either I choose or he will choose, as I was getting one. . I did like ...