Minnewaska Lodge

3116 Route 44-55, Gardiner, New York, 12525, United States | 3 star hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.
 

Travel Blogs from Gardiner

Day 5 - Woodbury Common in the rain

A travel blog entry by christisonclan

... I thought it best Kylie and the kids get a cab so I called Kylie and arranged it. I walked to 47th and 8th and arrived just in time to catch the guy going in to open up the ticket office. The documentation and website say you MUST collect the bus tickets from 8th and 47th before getting the bus. The ticket office opened at 7am and the first bus left at 7;15am which gave me a very tight but doable window provided the Grayline staff oblige by opening on time. The guy at the ticket ...

Home Base- Where it all begins

A travel blog entry by farmhouse

1

... life: a study abroad trip to Ecuador.

The intention of this blog is to maintain connection with Diane. It is a place where we can all communicate through pictures and words, to shorten the distance not only between New York and Ecuador, but between Grove, Oakwood, and Wurtz streets.

We will all miss you Diane (and Julie & Chelsea)
and welcome back Lezzy and Jacqui~~
...

Girls Weekend 2013!

A travel blog entry by laceybronwyn

2

... and jumped in the hot tub. It was wonderful. After a few hot toddys, Mary and I decided it would be a good idea to jump out of the tub and make snow angels in our bathing suits. Yes, there is a video.

So in the end the weekend turned out to be a whole lot of doing nothing and it was perfect in every way. We're hoping for another trip up there over the weekend between Christmas and New Year.


...

World record, Hudson Valley and Thanksgiving

A travel blog entry by rene77

119

... NY institution, on the way to Wong and I convinced Matt to go in on our way home so I could try some of the delicious cakes, biscuits and cannoli!

On Sunday morning Matt and I did a spin class; trying to make a small dent in all the overindulgence of the past few days…

On Monday I had an appointment at the doctor for a full medical. Matt’s work insurance is great so we might as well take advantage of it while we’re here! I had to get ...

Goodbye Hurley, Thanks for all the Memories

A travel blog entry by mcmactravels

3

... experience immensely and stayed in the Engine room for two rides while Kevin took his fiddle back to the coaches and played some rollicking music for the kiddos. Merry Christmas!

We spent a bit of time packing up and getting the farmhouse back in order after living there (very happily) for two months. I had to day goodbye to some of my food projects and Kevin had to put away the sewing machine, for ...

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.

Location

This 3 star hotel, located on 3116 Route 44-55, Gardiner, is near Minnewaska State Park Preserve, Mohonk Preserve, Shawangunk Mountains, and Jenkinstown Day Spa.
Map this hotel

Amenities

View all amenities
       

    Historical Traveler Reviews Minnewaska Lodge Gardiner

    Love it more and more

    from

    We've stayed here 5 times so far - in both summer and winter. We've fallen in love with the lodge as much as we've fallen in love with the New Paltz area, and for similar reasons. The Lodge abutts beautiful mountains, it's comfortable/cozy with an outdoors feel in design and materials, and the people (other lodgers and the staff) are friendly. The staff is also helpful, and we love the bowls of apples and afternoon cookies, as well as the more than ample Continental breakfasts (it's midway between Continental and a full offering). Actually, it's too good. I find it hard to stop myself from overeating. I agree with the dissenting reviews that walls could be more sound-proof, but it has yet to be a problem. I also agree that the few (two?) rooms adjacent to the close-by small parking lot are initially a dissapointment, but even when we had one of these rooms, it's really not a problem - we're out during the day, and we sleep with the curtains closed to keep the light out. The common areas (one indoor, one out) are large and comfortable. We even like just hanging out there talking, reading, playing games, and meeting others. There's also an exercise room with equipment, but we've yet to use it... We've so enjoyed our stays at the Lodge we have sent 5 other couples here in just the year since we discovered it. They have all thanked us! PS: It's a short easy drive from New Paltz, and on the way to the Minnewaska State Park Preserve.

    Great Hospitality

    from

    Minnewaska Lodge is clean and beautiful. This year we stayed in the suite and particularly liked it - we will request it next year.The staff was very helpful and pleasant - they let us check in early which was greatly appreciated after a long trip. Breakfast was yummy! We'll be back next year.

    Solid in Many Ways

    from

    We've stayed at Minnewaska Lodge the last two years, meeting friends from NJ (New Paltz somewhat midway), and they've referred many happy customers, as well. It's a well maintained, very tastefully designed and decorated place, with attentive management and attention to detail. When I asked the owner about his biggest surprise about owning an inn (a relatively new career, after law), he said "having to fix everything right away." And it's clear that they do. The place looks both classic and brand new. Plus, the setting is gorgeous, just close enough to the Gunks and New Paltz, and just far enough away from civilization. I did notice the noise from another room, which was in the normal range (no party) and concur they don't have the most solid walls, but it's in no way for me something to knock down the rating from excellent. There has been nothing to dissuade anyone in our discerning group to reconsider that this will continue as our "same time, next year" first resort.

    Loved Minnewaska Lodge

    from

    My husband and I stayed at Minnewaska Lodge for the last three summers. It's a wonderful retreat for us when we go to visit our son..

    The people that work there are the best! The scenery is magnificent. We are looking forward to going there again.

    Perfect retreat.

    from

    I have been to Minnewaska Lodge several times since it opened - usually for a quick get away, but last time for a few days midweek. The rooms are tastefully furnished but not frilly - always very clean. Nice mission furniture. There is great hiking/biking and swimming at Minnewaska State Park and a lot of good places to eat nearby. Our last trip we went up to Rhinebeck which was only about a half hour and had a great dinner and enjoyed a movie and walking around town. The views of the cliff are wonderful - like another world. Midweek is great - less expensive and nothing was crowded. Great escape!

    Overrated - problems

    from

    I have to disagree with the previous positive reviews. The positive -- The hotel is in a very scenic location -- but make sure you get a room facing the spectalular backdrop of the the Catskill mountain, rather than the parking lot.

    Minnewaska Lodge is great weekend retreat

    from

    I must disagree with the negative reviews I just read. My experience at M.L. was top notch. The staff was very helpful, the setting was specatular and the breakfast was just want we wanted. We did not hear any extraordinary loud noises from the hotel. We wanted a weekend getaway, didn't want to spend Mohonk prices and wanted to be close to all the action. The Lodge delivered. It's not cheap, but considering the area, I thought it was reasonable. I don't like B&B's. I don't want to feel like I am in someone's house. I want the relative anonimity of a hotel, but I don't want some corporate hole like Super 8. That is why the Lodge was ideal for our needs.

    Works for Us

    from

    Minnewasaka Lodge is the perfect retreat for me and my husband. While I enjoy the magnificent view and reading on the deck for hours, my husband is still connected and plugs into the hi-speed internet access as soon as we arrive. Each time we stay at the Lodge (3, so far!) we walk in the woods by day and eat in fabulous restaurants at night --all just moments from what has become our own mountain retreat. No complaints here--we plan to return this summer!

    Wonderful lodge!

    from

    I stayed at Minnewaska Lodge with my family several times since they oppend a couple of years ago and we have always had a wonderful time. The rooms are great, with comfortable king size beds, large TV's, fabulous views, cathedral ceiling and a deck. The lodge is a real gem for those who appreciate staying off the beaten track in a hotel with real character and charm.

    Terrible weekend

    from

    My girlfriend and I stayed at the Minnewaska Lodge over a recent weekend for a quick (and hopefully quiet) getaway from Manhattan. We were, to say the least, highly dissapointed in the Lodge. While the surroundings were beautiful (including the nearby Catskill Mts), the Minnewaska Lodge left us feeling that we hadn't had the nice, quiet weekend we sought away from Manhattan. Two main complaints: (1) the Lodge is so poorly constructed that you can hear every footstep, every conversation, every sneeze, of any adjoining room in the Lodge (and we were in a corner room). (2) I booked a room facing the mountains with a King size bed and was instead given a room with two small beds facing the parking lot. When we complained, we received a small discount, an explanation that no other room was available all weekend and significant attitude from the hotel manager. This was inexcusable. The free breakfast was mediocre at best. While the nearby Mohonk Mt Lodge is overpriced and the food is sub-par, look for some alternative -- anything other than the Minnewaska Lodge -- unless you don't value privacy, quiet surroundings, and assurances that the room you booked is the room you will be checked into.

    TripAdvisor Reviews Minnewaska Lodge Gardiner

    4.50 of 5 stars Outstanding