Travelers also recommend:
Historical Traveler Reviews Clarendon Hotel Edinburgh
Cheap and cheerful!
This hotel has some excellent last minute deals!
We managed to find a double room at £40.00, including breakfast!
The hotel has just been refurbished and looks nothing like the pictures in all the guides.
For the location of the hotel and the price I don't think you would find anything better. Right on the doorstep of Princes St!
Wow!, what an improvement!
After staying at this hotel last year, when the hotel, to be honest was not looking it's best, I thought I'd give it another try following it's refurbishment.
All I can say is that I am amazed by it's transformation! The rooms are now modern and birght and the public areas are now inviting and cosy. After a hearty breakfast I checked out with a completely transformed opinion of the hotel.
The customer isn't always right (apparently)
After having read reviews of the Maitland on Tripadvisor - mainly bad but some hopeful, I thought I'd give them the benefit of the doubt and decided to accommodate a colleague of mine there for 2 nights. On arrival, not only was the entire hotel being renovated to such an extent that he was tripping over rolls of wallpaper in the hallways, but he was kept up by someone tiling the bathroom beneath his room until 10pm, when he'd been assured by the receptionist that it would be finished by 7pm. There's no excuse to keep a hotel open when the renovations are so widespread and I've spent the last 4 weeks complaining to the manager, who's shown no interest in apologising, let alone refunding and now they're not even returning my calls. Thumbs down for the Maitland.
What to people expect!!
My boyfriend and i have just come back from spending a few days in Edinburgh - i read the reviews on this site before we went - for the location and price we got exactly what you would expect - very clean, friendly staff. you cant expect to stay in a 3star hotel and expect 5 star accomodation!! if we vistied Edinburgh again we would rebook the Maitland.
Provides a decent place to sleep!
This hotel is a good choice if all you require is a clean, warm, and safe room. The complimentary breakfast is served promptly and the staff is friendly. The location is excellent. Although the hotel does require redecorating, it provides a decent stay for people on a budget who only plan to spend their sleeping hours at the hotel.
Better than expected
Like one of your other reviewers we read the comments of previous visitors with a mixture of horror and amusement, prior to our visit this weekend. My friend even rang the hotel to ask if it was as bad as it sounded, and was told "well maybe it does need a lick of paint, but we try our best to make visitors feel welcome.." Well, they were right.
OK, it's not a 5 star hotel and doesn't pretend to be, and yes, it definitely needs an overhaul (planned for this autumn), but the staff were more than helpful, the beds comfortable, and the location could not have been better placed for either the city centre, or the airport transfer.
Anyway, in such a buzzing, fabulous city as Edinburgh at festival time, who wants to spend all the time in a hotel? Chill out, I say.
No decent travel agent should recommend this hotel
My boyfriend and I stayed at the Maitland Townhouse during the last week of May 2003 and we were also extremely digusted with this hotel.
It was hideously misrepresented on its website. It was a dank and dark hotel with no charm at all. The room we reserved was a double with a shower. We received a 10x10 room which could barely hold all of the furniture that they squeezed into it. We had to put our suitcase in the timy walkway and climb over it anytime we went to the bathroom. If we were not standing in the bathroom then we were sitting on the bed because there was no where else to go. The bathroom only had a bathtub and unfortunately they were not able to accommodate us with us another room. The restaurant was terrible. Just getting milk and juice from a staff member was a challenge. The hotel also offered no guest parking and the closest pay lot was about 1 mile away by the castle. I would not recommend this hotel to my worst enemy. Spend the few extra bucks and stay at the Caledonian right next to it. the best comparison that I can give between the two is Caesar's Palace to a garden shack.
We stayed 4 nights at the Maitland Hotel in Edinburgh. If I had not been with a tour group and basically "stuck", I would have quickly moved on to something else. The rooms were shabby and not very clean. Our shower/tub leaked and when mopping up, the towel was filthy from the bathroom floor. Luckily I had brought thongs so I could avoid walking on the carpet and the bathroom floor. On the positive side, the staff was very freindly & attentive, the food was fairly good in their restaurant, the sheets were clean and the location was excellent for visiting Edinburgh Castle and the historic area of Edinburgh. I do think with a little looking you could find a bit nicer place to stay.
Old but clean and warm , and friendly!
I read the review you have on here from the canadian gentleman and was disturbed because i was due to stay at the Maitland on the following night..
However upon arriving i was so pleasantly surprised..yes the hotel is old...then again it is in the old quarter of this beautiiful city....But the friendliness of the reception staff and the warmth of the hotel far made up for this....The room was small but adeqate, very warm and very clean....Perhaps the bathrooms do need renovating but they were clean and to me that is more important.
I work in a travel agency and wouldn certainly recommend this hotel to my clients.....i think that is confidence enough...
I booked the Maitland Townhouse Hotel for a two night stay through their web site. From the web site, the hotel looked great - tastefully decorated, good desctiption of a quaint, thpical townhouse hotel in Edinburgh. When we arrived at the hotel by taxi last week, we thought we were at the wrong address. This hotel has no charm or ambiance. The lobby is tiny, with grease stained walls. The rooms are also very small, and look like they were last decorated in the 40's, with threadbare bedspreads, etc. They look like the kind of room you would rent out by the hour. The bathrooms are painted a florid orange colour - we looked at 2 rooms because we couldntr believe thery were all as bad as the one we were first shown. And all for 78 pounds a night - $190.00 Canadian.
My husband and I quickly deciced we could not stay at the Maitland. We walked around the corner and got a room at the Caledonian, one of Edinburgh's finest hotels for 120 pounds a ight including full breakfast. The only positive thing I can say about the Maitland is that they let us out of our reservatin. this hotel was totally misrepresented onit's web site.
TripAdvisor Reviews Clarendon Hotel Edinburgh
Travel Blogs from Edinburgh
... that most of the time it’s cloudy and to this day it is still useless. The last building that was a big oops was the one that was meant to warn sailors below in the sea that is was 1pm and time to start coming back in. There would be a shiny ball on top of the building that would drop so if the sailors couldn’t see the ball, then it would be past 1pm. Unfortunately the clouds would be covering this most of the time so it too became useless. The hill we were on may ...
... so much, been so much throughout the ages that you have to marvel that they still stand. We go to have some lunch and are pleased to hear a quartet of pipers out on the street playing. These are four 20 something lads with some real talent.
Just down the street is a place called Glandstone's Land. This is a house that has been refurbished to the year 1617. Once again it tells you the history of the people, who could have afforded the flats. They have wonderful ...
Today we visited Edinbrugh Castle. ▪️Fierce Iron Age warriors defended a hill fort here, and the nations oldest poetry tells of a war band feasting here for a year before riding to their deaths in battle The scots and English struggled for control of the castle ...
... Auckland. He batted at 3 and got bowled for 15, the team made 166 from 45 overs and won the day, must have fielded well. Jack kept for the whole game so that was great for him. Then tonight they went to a T20 game at the Emirates Stadium in Durham, Yorkshire vs Durham County and the kids in their tour shirts were asked to do a lap of honour around the ground before the game, so special for them! Tomorrow they are off to Blackpool for the day to an amusement park, boy ...
... the shark reef aquarium, a four day monorail pass, 3 Buffet passes, another restaurant meal, fresh crÍpes, drink credit in a piano bar and lordy lordy one or two other things as well. It's saving us a stack of money. Speaking of savings we just found a cheeper deal on our hotel as well. So we called up reservations and saved our selves another $200. Well the cocktail and shopping kitty is looking better for all this, you should see the smile on Gail’s ...