Kildonan Lodge Hotel

Address: 27 Craigmillar Park, Edinburgh, Scotland, EH16 5PE, United Kingdom | 4 star hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.


This 4 star hotel, located in the Cameron Toll area of Edinburgh, is near Surgeons' Hall, University of Edinburgh, The Queen's Hall, and The Royal Observatory.
Map this hotel



    Historical Traveler Reviews Kildonan Lodge Hotel Edinburgh

    Great weekend in Edinburgh


    We stayed for 3 nights at this hotel, we could'nt have asked for more, the room was very comfortable and well presented. There is free parking at the back of the hotel which was a bonus, they also had free broadband wireless internet, this was handy as I brought my laptop with me, they also have a computer that guests can use.

    Breakfast was good and the staff were very helpful.

    I would definately recommend this hotel to other travellers, we would stay here again when we next visit Edinburgh.

    Excellent accommodation - give it a try!


    We stayed at the Kilodonan Lodge for our 45th wedding anniversary in May 2006 and had a wonderful time - spotlessly clean, fantastic breakfasts and wonderful staff. Give it a try!

    Loved Kildonan Lodge Hotel


    Our family of four stayed at Kildonan Lodge Hotel in March, 2006 for 2 nights at the beginning of a three-week holiday throughout Scotland and England. We chose this hotel largely as a result of positive reviews on this site, the reasonable price and the location (a quick cab ride to the Royal Mile).

    Although we booked a moderate family room, we were upgraded to a lovely large room on the second floor with a four-poster double bed, a single bed and a cot, all decked out in green tartan. The room had a very large bay window overlooking the front so it was very bright, but had blackout drapes that kept both the light and the noise down. The ensuite bath was small but very nice and clean.

    We loved relaxing in the parlour every evening after returning from dinner, using the well-stocked honesty bar. Frauke, the day manager, and Sean, the night porter, couldn't have been more welcoming and helpful, and they would happily make us a pot of tea anytime. The dining room was lovely and bright, and we really enjoyed the hearty and delicious Scottish breakfast each morning.

    This hotel was a real find and was one of the highlights of our trip.

    Superb hotel with that touch of class


    Having stayed at this hotel in late november 2005 I didnt even consider anywhere else when it came to my most recent visit to Edinburgh. The staff were a joy and the rooms spacious and tastefully presented. the guests lounge with its honesty bar and warm atmosphere are an absolute joy. The breakfasts are simply outstanding. I look forward to my next visit to Edinburgh, guess where I will be staying.

    Wonderful Hospitality in Edinburgh


    Stayed here in September 2005, after deciding to spend our 2 weeks holiday at home in Scotland.

    Had stayed in Ediburgh at a previous B&B, and although it was wonderful, not central enough. The Kildonan Lodge Hotel was the best of both worlds, with spotless, freshly decorated rooms, crisp linen and a very central location.

    Our room was probably one of the smaller, but the price reflected this, and it was well worth the money (still a double with dresser, chair, side tables, coffee area and trouser press, plus ensuite!)

    The staff were very friendly and helpful, with a warm welcoming reception, bar to the right, and restaurant to the left. Ample parking on arrival, and easy to find (yet quiet).

    The Skerries Restaurant serves wonderful locally produced food, and was out of this world - a great bottle of wine topped off a fantastic meal.

    Clearly the great atmosphere had an effect on us, as we decided to get engaged during our visit - what more could you want?!

    Would definitely recommend.

    Never again


    We booked in here for 4 nights and left after the first. When we arrived we noticed that bed sheets were dirty and has not been changed from the previous guest. I complained and they were changed immediately. My wife went to take a bath and that had not been cleaned either. We left early the next morning skipping breakfast.



    booked in may 05 got there 01/10/05 at 3/o clock laft 3/30pm. terrible four poster room .

    Lovely hotel, Excellent food


    We stayed here in June 04.

    We chose to stay here as my friend and I had graduated that day and we wanted to have a meal with our families. The food in Potters was excellent and the service was wonderful. The staff made us feel really special.

    My husband & I stayed the night here, The rooms were very comfortable and quiet.

    Would definately go back again!!!

    Loved it!!


    We stayed here with my then Fiancee and he proposed officially in the room with the jacuzzi and the 4 poster bed!!

    Lovely room, lovely hotel, bus stop just outside the hotel and not too far into town.

    We went to the Italian resturaunt - Juliannos (or something like that) and it was excellent!! Well recommend but fills up real fast so you need to book in advance!!

    Hope to come back soon with my now husband!!

    A great night to remember!


    Very enjoyable stay. Very friendly and welcolming. Rooms are clean and comfortable. Even though it is 1 and 1/2 miles from the centre, there is a bus stop right outside and the buses are regular. Get a day pass - cheap and you can use any bus. You must eat in Potters. The food is top notch and the service is fantastic. My fiance proposed to me there and it was a night to remember. The food, lighting, soft music and attentive staff. I will be coming back!

    TripAdvisor Reviews Kildonan Lodge Hotel Edinburgh

    4.50 of 5 stars Outstanding

    Travel Blogs from Edinburgh

    Bonnie, Bonnie Edinburgh!!!

    A travel blog entry by eurotrekker01 on Sep 28, 2015

    ... the layout along with the people and the great food. Yes food, I say, there is some scrumptious stuff here and in some cases it’s so good that we have gone back to the same restaurant twice in the last two nights.

    Well before I continue I would like to say how much we enjoyed our time in Inverness, it really is a beautiful part of Scotland and should not be missed should you be anywhere near it in your travels. While we were there we ...

    Och aye we gart it tae scootlund!

    A travel blog entry by mweiss.history on Jul 20, 2015

    14 photos

    ... and walking/climbing. Our destination was Honister Slate Mine, and the journey once we left the highway was incredibly picturesque, but the roads as we got further up into the hills became increasingly narrow. We had a few close calls with other local busses, but our drive Arek did a fabulous job in navigating the tiny stone roadways! Because the drive up took a bit longer than we had budgeted ...

    Edinburgh day two: don't diss Mary Queen of Scots

    A travel blog entry by emily.picardi on Apr 13, 2015

    7 photos

    ... From the abbey you walk through the gardens of the palace, which are beautiful. My favorite part of the gardens is a freaky looking statue of a fiddler tucked way in the back of the garden. The face is crumbling away and the body is sort of contorted, Quasimodo style. As my brother said, it looks like the next monster Sam and Dean will face on Supernatural.

    After our visit to Holyrood I decided I was too tired and needed a nap, so I went back to the flat. My mom and ...

    Some last minute shopping

    A travel blog entry by catwatson on Dec 13, 2014

    6 photos

    ... way it would of fit in our suitcase. A bit more browsing and shopping and a lunch stop at McDonald's (first time in Edinburgh), they had a different Christmas menu including a warm banoffee pie filled with chocolate, caramel and banana.....YUMMY!!! Hope to put our shopping away and get ready to head out to Julie's sister in laws for tea. Of course our day was filled with fun and laughter as everyday prior has been. One last day tomorrow then we are off to start our journey ...

    Not just tea and scones

    A travel blog entry by lynnyslonglaugh on Aug 21, 2014

    5 photos

    On my final day, I joined my host Lindsay and her friends at a Women's Institute meeting. The Scottish Women's Rural Institutes is one of the largest women's organisations in Scotland and boasts about 18,489 members. Lindsay's chapter is more urban than most rurals with a much younger average age than most other WIs. Just like normal WI meetings, the Rural ...