Historical Traveler Reviews of Hotel Wolcott New York City
Great Value!
from A TripAdvisor Member
Great value hotel - rooms were comfortable and pleasant, staff were helpful, everything worked...most importantly it was CLEAN. Obviously not the most plush hotel around, but it is more than functional if you are not going to be spending much time there. Location is excellent, the street its located on is a bit dark and dingy but once you get out onto 5th Ave you're in the middle of it all.
Decent budget hotel
from A TripAdvisor Member
We spent nine nights at the Wolcott. Overall, the hotel was quite nice considering the rate. The lobby was quite grand, nicely restored and ornamented and the rooms were moderate, but clean and the bed was firm and ok. TV worked, some trouble with the signal with some channels.
Complimentary muffins, coffee and tea were served in the lobby, which was a nice surprise. Location is excellent, just a couple of blocks from the Empire State Building, Macy's and Penn Station. The two elevators were small and slow, and one of them malfunctioned one evening, but it was repaired before the next morning. The hallways seemed somewhat worndown. Maid visited everyday. If you want a clean,basic and affordable place where to stay and rest your bones in a good location in Manhattan, then I guess the Wolcott is just fine.
Don't expect anything fancy or room service or anything like that.
There were no problems (except the one elevator one night) during our stay. Overall we got good value for our money.
Great Stay
from A TripAdvisor Member
We stayed at the Hotel Wolcott from 15th November until 22nd November 2003. We were very pleasantly surprised after reading bad reviews on the hotel and thought we had made a mistake booking it based on the price. We found the staff to be perfectly pleasant and the triple room we booked was great. Really spacious with two twin beds in one section and another one round the corner in another part of the room which gave the feeling of privacy and your own TV! The room was very clean and comfortable and the hotel was located in a great part of town within walking distance of Times Square and just round the corner from the Empire State building. No complaints from us at all.
It was OK...
from A TripAdvisor Member
Yes, the room was clean and the bathroom was OK. The room was very small. I think i'ts a good price, we paid 99 USD/night for a twin bed room. But the staff was very unhelpful and no service minded at all.
Would visit again!
from A TripAdvisor Member
Was pleasantly surprised for the price of the hotel. The room was spacious and clean, and had a great view of the Empire State Building from the window. The area is not great, but it's relatively quiet, and is well positioned to get to all the tourist spots easily. Would definitely go again, as you couldn't beat the price for the centre of NYC.
Stepping back in time
from A TripAdvisor Member
It was like stepping back in time. The place is 100 years old and still looks great. They kept the decorations the same. Wow
Loved it
from A TripAdvisor Member
I liked the hotel is was clean and resonable priced. I do not know what the other reviews are talking about. For the price no place had free breakfest
Nasty hotel
from A TripAdvisor Member
We stayed here for economical reasons, but there are hotels of a similar price range in the area that looked far nicer. We had reserved a room for an agreed price but on arrival the clerk asked us to sign something quoting a far higher price. The rooms are dull, dingy and the staff are awful. I do not consider the location to be particularly good either, yes it is next to the empire state building & near Macys but uptown is far nicer.
Down and Out!
from kenfrohling
If you are down on your luck, this may be the place for you. We booked because we thought the location was good for a budget hotel. Well, that was about all that was good.
The rooms were OK, but a bit run down. THe service, however, was awful.
It seemed liked every person that we interacted with had a permanent frown and really did not want to be there. Neither did we!
It's OK
from bubas99
hotels OK. A bit dingy but it's cheap.
Good location, but let down by very unfriendly staff.