How has this hotel rated in the past?
Photos of Hotel Tresanton
Historical Traveler Reviews Hotel Tresanton St Mawes
GOOD VIEW,LITTLE ELSE GOOD
We visited the hotel in July 2003 as we had a wedding to attend in st Mawes. Stepping into our room I was overcome by a very musty smell as if the room hadn't been aired or used in a long time. Looking out at the beautiful scenery, we stepped outside unto the terrace only to be tangled up in overgrown weeds. We contacted reception who sent someone up to cut them back, so we had to enjoy the scenery from inside the room. That evening we dined in their restaurant only to have to eat our meal with smoke bellowing around us from their blocked chimney, but we did get a glass of champagne as compensation!! On checking out we pointed out our problems only to be told "Oh sorry about that Sir! nothing else. When we got home we wrote to the manager and were refunded the money for the meal. We actually find it strange that it seems to held in such high regard, all I can say is 'Don't believe the hype'.
Expensive but pretty impressive
Stayed here in Spring, 2004 and liked it a lot. The room that we had was very spacious and the weather helped in that it was really warm and sunny and we had the view out to the bay from both the room and the terrace.
Couldn't really fault this hotel other than the price you have to pay for it - it's pretty expensive however you look at it.
The only thing I'd say is that whilst the food at Dinner was good it wasn't amazing - had much better food at Percy's.
The best hotel in the UK
Due to the nature of my business I have now stayed in almost every decent hotel in the UK and Tresanton is by far my favourite- it is the highlight of my regular trips over to England. The food is as good as I have eaten and the cocktails in the bar are up their with those in the top bars of London and New York.
Will give it a try
Only came here for dinner, as we were staying at the excellent Driftwood nearby (when we booked it was a tight decision between the two). From an evening in the hotel, I will definately come back and stay. The location is lovely , straight on the sea, and all communal areas are impressive.
We couldnt get a taxi back to our hotel, so the restaurant manager gave us a lift. Little touches of added service like this will ensure that I return for longer.
A treat, but certainly worth it. A luxury hotel, which is beautifully decorated. Staff very attentive. Food excellent. Definitely going back.
Im a little baffled by some of the posts here. This place is fantastic in every way. The rooms (ive stayed in ) are superb. Make sure you go for 5,6 or 7. 6 & 7 have their own private balconies.The food is great, there not a great deal of choice however they do rely on locally caught seafood so there is an ever changing menu.The Victory Pub is to be avoided in my opinion, I like nothing better than a decent boozer but the food is so expensive - Over £10 for any Main and for a pub this really is too much.The staff are fantastic, nothing is too much trouble and there is never a feeling of 'is that going to cost me a fortune' that you get at some luxury hotels - such as Blake's in Amsterdam for instance.The last stay (2003 August Bank Holiday) was my Birthday and my Mother had pre-ordered a Bottle of Wine for me for Dinner along with a Card some weeks before. When I had arrived they phoned my Mother (without my knowledege) and let her know that myself and my girlfriend had arrived safely and were in good hands! Very nice touch even if I am in my late 20's!!The Rooms are expensive but the experience is priceless. Ive been there 3 times and am going again next August. A recent stay there last weekend cost £800 for 2 people including Dinner/Breakfast and all drinks etc...The area is stunning and St Mawes is probably the nicest Village in Cornwall. If you want a change from the view/hotel pop to the Pandora Inn pub in Mylor - much better than the Victory Inn in a lovely location.The Tresanton is the best hotel Ive been to in the World.
Overhyped and overpriced !
I can only agree with the rather more negative reviews of the hotel tresanton. Certainly the room that we stayed in could best be described as poky. If you decide to go, be sure to ask which room they intend to allocate. Beware rooms 17-21 are all very small and if the weather is hot which it was when we visited they get very warm indeed as there is no airconditioning. The setting of the hotel is beautiful and the service is good but I still think that they rely a little too much on their trendy reputation, and that the actual experience is not worth the money. The food in the restaurant is very average and horribly overpriced. The best advice I can give anyone whoo intends to stay here is to avoid it completely and eat at the Victory Inn in St Mawes which does possibly the best seafood we had ever tasted for about half the price
A Good Attempt!
The Tresanton is a good attempt at making Cornwall 'trendy'. It occupies a wonderful site in the very picturesque cornish fishing village of St Mawes and is only a 5-hour trip from London by car or train.As such, the many of the guests are from London looking for a chic weekend getaway and as London is the main market, we expected it to be a little 'chicer' than it actually was.In terms of UK standards, the hotel is good, but in terms of Far East standards it is a bit shabby around the edges...everything is relative but £225 ($340) per room per night (including breakfast) is not cheap by any standards.The hotel is comfortable. It has a wonderful cosy lounge with a roaring log fire and quirky decor, with artifacts from around the world and funky stingray shaped lights. There is a downstairs bar which is as modern and trendy (also with a cosy lounge area).The whole of the hotel (except the restaurant) has seagrass matting on the floor, which works well in the public areas but is uncomfortable in the bedrooms (too trendy perhaps?)The rooms are good, but not fantastic. There are some in the main building and some further up the hill in an annexe, where the sea views are better from a small balcony but where space is more limited. The rooms are simply furnished with no tea/coffee making facilities, no hairdryer and no iron. The plumbing is 'eccentric English' and plays wonderful tunes throughout the night. Although the shower and bath are good, the taps in our basin did not work properly, another small niggle. The rooms are noisy and it is easy to hear those staying next door and upstairs! There needs to be more attention to detail.The staff at reception and those dealing with baggage/valet parking etc are very good, friendly and willing to deal with any query.The restaurant occupies prime location on the first floor and in the summer spills out onto a wonderful terrace with a distinct nautical feel and fantastic views over the Fal Estuary. The food is well presented but 'average'. The supervisory staff are excellent (especially the Scottish Lady), but on her day off, things fall apart and the service becomes very erratic from the mixture of nationalities serving the tables.Despite the tables in the restaurant being small and closely packed in, the candle-lit ambiance is very romantic. However the food has tinges of 'big hotel catering' about it...it tries to be modern and funky, but doesn't quite get there. Orders are mixed up, food arrives on cold plates and it is all a bit more stressful than it should be for a fixed price of £34 ($51) per person. A seafoof risotto appetiser was excellent with scallops cooked to perfection but served on a cold plate. John Dory as a main course was good, but the dish was overcooked and swimming in butter. Calves liver was served on mashed potato, but with insufficient gravy. The cheese selection was meagre and the types of cheese offered were poor..such a shame when England (and Cornwall) produces some of the best cheeses in the world.The food and service does not come up to the standard that weekending Londoners would expect for the price they are paying (Olga Polizzi, the owner should take note!).The wine list is good, if a bit quirky, but markups are high. On our second evening, we strolled into the village to the Rising Sun pub/restaurant and enjoyed an equally good, if not better meal, with superior service.Breakfast however is excellent, with a good choice of buffet items and a good a la carte selection including full English Breakfast, scambled egg with smoked salmon, field mushrooms on toast, kippers, choice of eggs etc etc, all served with lashings of coffee and toast and marmelade.....excellent!Altogether, this is a good hotel and provides for an enjoyable stay, but a two night stay out of season (early March) cost £500 ($750) for the two of us (including one night's dinner)........quite a hefty bill!Very nice, but over-hyped would be our verdict!
Well we loved Hotel Tresanton!
I was so surprised to read the review of a guest who had stayed at Tresanton as we have just returned from a fabulous weekend at the same hotel. Unlike the other guest, I recognised many of the objets in the hotel to be from local and nationally recognised artists - the furniture is as comfortable as one could wish for, the style as good as the hype, all rooms have been decorated with the ambience in mind. The bar was quiet when we visited but certaintly nothing wrong with it - the plumbing was fine on our visit and the food excellent. The staff were charming and really made the visit for us - we will return! The style of Tresanton does not suit everyone but if you like it, you'll go back again and again.
A taste of Cornwall
A great deal of money and effort has been invested in the Tresanton Hotel to provide a very specific and "tasteful" environment. While the restaurant has a minimalist Mediterranean feel, the rest of the hotel is very "British" country style. Bedrooms and lounges are adorned with a variety of seemingly second hand furniture. They are not antiques - just old fashioned. The emphasis is on style rather than comfort or practicality. The beds are comfortable, but we were surprised to find that the "second hand" style extended to a hole in the bed linen! It is unfortunate that the style continues into the bathroom. It imitates the plumbing of the days before decent showerheads and mixer taps. So when washing your hands you either scald yourself or use cold water. An inadequate hot towel rail provides bathroom heating so that you get goose pimples on exiting the shower or bath. And the mirrors all steam up and have to be cleaned before you can see yourself to shave or comb hair.
The kitchen is excellent and we were not disappointed with any dish. Dinner is a fixed three-course affair. But what comes is first class. Whether the £30 charge is appropriate in provincial UK another matter. The staff are mainly young and enthusiastic. They provide good service without being obtrusive. They have great skill in fitting glasses, plates, bread condiments, wine etc onto the stupidly small dining tables. There is rumoured to be a cinema in the hotel but we never found it. The bar has all the charm of a British railway station buffet and is best avoided.
At £235 per night for bed and breakfast the Tresanton is an expensive way for a couple to see how the British relax by the sea.
TripAdvisor Reviews Hotel Tresanton St Mawes
Travel Blogs from St Mawes
We left The Rudloe Arms and hit the misty highway to head south into the heart of the West Country: Cornwall. We'd heard about the Eden Project for years and seeing as though we were down this way it was a no-brainer. Jen found tickets on-line that also allowed us into the cool sounding "Lost Garden of Heligan." Seeing as it was only 10 miles from Eden, again, it was a no-brainer. The Eden Project also has a YHA hostel in the grounds and we booked a ...
... hedge fences and rolling countryside, and quite a few rivers to cross along the way, spilling onto the Atlantic at Portsmouth, Exmouth, Plymouth and Dartmouth among others.
Cornwall has its own language; a Gaelic tongue, but not Irish, Welsh or Scottish. Can't wait to try a proper Cornish Pasty.
We pass through Looe, Catchfrench, ...
A bit of a blah day but only because I suffered from heart burn half the night and was a bit washed out in the morning. A day to do the washing and pack our bags. We still managed to fit in a bike ride up to Silbyback Lake and back to blow out the cobwebs. It's about an hours ride and the wind went right through you. It was very pretty but so cold. Kerry did the honours and cooked dinner for everyone ...
... s place and when we arrived it was raining so the general consensus was to go for coffee. Great idea as by the time we'd finished the sun was out and St Ives was looking glorious and the water was beautiful. It made us want to swim. We walked around the coast and along a lovely beach and looking up at the hill there was quite a large cemetery and I commented that they had the ...
... only to be told they had no electricity and could only serve cold food. We all trooped out to find the next pub and it was even cuter. Kerry could only just fit under the roof and in some parts of the pub he had to duck under the beams. We were all served a lovely meal in a cozy room and then we headed off for our walk home ...