Hotel Plaza Athenee New York
How has this hotel rated in the past?
- Shuttle bus service
- Minbar in room
- Wireless internet connection in public areas
- Smoking rooms available
Photos of Hotel Plaza Athenee New York
Historical Traveler Reviews Hotel Plaza Athenee New York New York City
I have stayed in NYC many times. The last two times were at the Four Seasons on 57th. Because I found the Four Seasons in NYC not up to my usual (Four Seasons) expectations I decided to try the Plaza Athenee. My family and I very much enjoyed our stay. The hotel staff was personable, the rooms were lovely, and the dining was very nice. The hotel is older, so you don't have a big flashy lobby (honestly -who cares?) the rooms are decorated with older furnishings and the bathrooms do have smaller sinks and dressing areas. However the towels, sheets and overall maintence of the hotel is really either up to, or better, than the Four Seasons on 57th. It is a quite little corner of Manhattan-very nice, we will go back again.
The only downside is that it is impossible, and I say impossible, to get a taxi from there to anywhere.
I went to the Plaza Athenee on a platinum Amex deal for a $460 room and although it was quite lovely and the service was excellent, I think that it was a bit overpriced. This is an old-fashioned, traditional, small hotel on the east side and it is a nice respite from the overly trendy places like the Gansevoort, etc. The room was quite large, but very traditional. No sleep timer on the tv which is an important thing to me. I think the only reason it is rated one of the "Top 50 HOtels" by quite a few groups is the service. Everyone was very formal but extremely accomodating and a room service request for hot milk at midnight arrived within 3 minutes every night. I observed quite a few well-turned-out European businessmen and I think this is what the hotel caters to.
Great hotel -- great staff
We just returned from a 4 day stay in New York at the Plaza Athenee. The quality of service was superb--we enjoyed the best personal attention we've ever received at a hotel, and we've stayed at some very nice hotels. The rooms were beautiful, and the location was great. The staff went above and beyond the call of duty to make sure that we had a very pleasant experience in New York. The hotel was very quiet and serene, but was definately child-friendly (my daughter enjoyed the room service chicken strips on the kid's menu). The children's entrance to Central park was only a block and a half away. The 68th street and 59th street subway stations were an easy walk, and the doorman was terrific at getting a taxi very quickly. I would definitely stay at the Plaza Athenee again!
A private hideaway in a wonderful city
This is a wonderful hotel. The staff are incredibly friendly and ensure that your every need is catered for without being over the top. The location is fantastic within easy reach of everywhere in this wonderful city. The rooms are huge and very well furnished and decorated. I have stayed in a number of NYC's top hotels and can't recommend the Plaza Athenee enough.
Not so romantic to stay here
I selected this hotel for a romance night, shock to see the painting of the ceiling was peeling before my eyes, i mean this is one of the greatest hotel so this was a surprise to see. our view, well there was no view, the romance was incredible, but we checked out and proceeded our adventure at the marquis marriott, what a view!!! so much for all the hoopla, your fired!
Really Great Place
I really enjoyed this plaza. The rooms are very nice. The staff is wonderful. The location is great...forget cabs and the subway, you're within walking distance to the great stores on Lexington, the Whitney, the Met, and the Guggenheim. Theirs a really nice french cafe on 65th, right around the corner. You're right off Central Park, and if you have kids, the zoo is five minutes away. Their turn down service was thorough. The rooms are a bit small and pricey, but very nice. I really really liked this place. My only quibble was they made a mistake on my credit card, compounded it with additional charges, then were a little slow getting back to me. But I would gladly stay at the Athenee again.
Superb Service and Accommodations
Being in the travel industry I have the priviledge of staying at some of the best hotels throughout the world and The Plaza Athenee NYC has been one of them. Stayed here for the first time at the beginning of February and had a wonderful experience. Very professional and attentive staff, rooms are HUGE by New York standards and the proximity to Madisson Ave and 5th Ave shopping was excellent. The experience begins with being greeted at the front door and escorted to a private desk where you are seated to check-in. From there you are personally escorted to your room while being informed of all hotel services, facilities and room ammenities. It's no wonder why "Sex and the City" chose the Plaza Athenee for filming. Extra touches such as free internet access in the lobby make this hotel not only an excellent choice for service, but an excellent value for your travel dollar.
Loved the suite
The Plaza Athenee was wonderful. We were lucky enough to get the one bedroom suite overlooking the neighborhood. It has a small, European type feel to it. The staff attends to your every need. Great location!
Central Park is right down the road and it's close to everything. We loved it. The bar and restaurant there are newly refurbished and are great. The concierge was knowledgable and helpful. I would not recommend this hotel for people with small children as there are no childrens programs. It is also very quiet and private. This hotel caters to older adults and people who like privacy, peace and quiet and luxury.
Absolutely Loved the Plaza Athenee
I have stayed in many hotels all over the world. This hotel was one of the best I have ever been to. The service, attention, food, rooms etc etc were excellent.
Forget the Waldorf Astoria, or The Plaza. The Plaza Athenee knocks spots off both of them.
TripAdvisor Reviews Hotel Plaza Athenee New York New York City
Travel Blogs from New York City
Wednesday 25/3 - Nice complementary breakfast at the hotel then off to explore the 'High Line' which is an old elevated railway line that has been transformed into a landscaped 'street' and very well done too. We are a few weeks early to see it at it's best when all the spring flowers bloom and trees blossom but well worth the visit anyway. It lead south toward Chelsea Market which Mikaela was keen to see so that was the next stop. An excellent ...
... which is just so amazing. I have wanted to see this show since I saw their Tony performance about two years ago and I am so happy with my decision. After the show, we got some dessert and hot chocolate and headed back to Long Island, where we all fell asleep as soon as we possibly could. We were exhausted but it was an amazing day.
Sunday we tried to wake up even earlier to beat the lines at TKTS. We wanted to get out of the house by 9:30. Our plans were complicated as we ...
... 100% that night so we left Katie and John to have a romantic dinner for two at Little Owl in the West Village which they loved.
On Katie and John’s last day they did a spot more shopping in the morning and saw the library and giant piano from the film Big in the Schwarz shop. We re-grouped back at the flat and then headed down to the West Village to walk the High Line. We stopped for lunch at the Cull ...
... of travelling.
I'm still very worried about the two long flights, NYC to LAX 6 hours then LAX to BNE 13.5 hours. Really hoping to get business class on the long flight as I need to keep my leg up as it's the only way I am comfortable at all. It's very hard to move and I stiffen up quickly.
Pete had to do most of the packing and reshuffling of all our luggage. 4 bags to check in and 3 carry on bags, including the two cars that were now found. ...
... at Tiffanys! What will we get at Tiffanys? The yellow diamond just a little out of our budget .... Too many millions needed. Sonia was a fantastic guide at Tiffanys. We were going to have lunch at Bergdorf Goodman but little time short so ventured back to The Plaza and had the mosr amazing quiche and salad (for you foodies it was fabulous - no bad food yet!) Carrie was calling from the Sex in the City bus and off we went to ...