Herald Square Hotel
How has this hotel rated in the past?
Travelers also recommend:
Historical Traveler Reviews Herald Square Hotel New York City
Hostel looking hotel
the first time i stayed at the Herald Square Htl was in 1995 and at that time this was really a bargain budget hotel. Good location in midtown, just 2 blocks from subway. it used to be clean and the rooms (most of 'em very dark if not in the street side) were nice and large enough for its category ...except the one i got for the 1st night that was as big as the size of the bed!
i've just came back from the Herald where i stayed again and the hotel is a complete dump right now. i am upset because i thought to find the same place it was years ago but this time i found it a little dirty (hair and other stuff in the toilet floor/sink) and right now the rooms really need to get a "high maintenance" to be again as nice as they used to be.
it's still a very good priced hotel especially for new york (payed $120.00 per night for a triple and have a big bargain with the garage where i parked for $20 per day) but be awared that right now it's more a hostel looking than a budget hotel as it used to be!
Perfect for the budget traveller
I stayed here in Nov02 and it was everything I was looking for. Great location, great price and clean. I was travelling solo and the single rooms were not huge, but you dont go to NY to spend time in your hotel room.
If you're looking for a room to sleep in, with a bathroom to clean up in, this will do. If you're used to lots of 'amenities' - toiletries in the bathroom, views, ironing board, etc. - this will seem awfully spartan. But my room was clean, the bathroom was _very_ clean, the mattress was comfortable, and the staff were quite accommodating. On the con side, I wouldn't want to spend too many nights there - the room was small, no question about it, and the airshaft didn't let in very much light. But for a short trip where budget is an issue, it was ideal. Oh, and the period magazine covers used as decoration in the lobby and hallways were charming.
Happy at the Herald
I came down to New York for a couple of days with my friends from school. This girl told me about the Herald Square Hotel and said it was perfect for students. It was clean and right in the center of the city. I could not have been happier. Thank You!
Mice and dirt at the Herald Square Hotel
I have worked at and stayed in many hotels. I read the reviews for this one and was prepared for a small room. It was tiny beyond belief with one tiny window that let in no light whatsover. Thankfully I am a Tube Train Driver and I am used to cramped dark, dirty conditions.
An ancient television with an incorrect flashing clock and a remote with a mind of its own. A tiny wardrobe, stained chair and no suitcase storage space. A sleepless night thanks to the noisy machinery of the building 6 feet away prompted me to buy earplugs for my second night. On my way to the one very slow elevator I saw a mouse scamper under someone's door, poor them I thought until a mouse paid me a visit in my room while I was about to get into bed.
Paint flaking from the bathroom ceiling falling through the false celiing, someone else's rubbish under the bed, not a place to stay. My request for an extended check out due to an evening flight was met with an unconditional 'check out time is 12pm'. Dust everywhere thanks to building works ( a sign appeared apologising on my last day)I wanted a budget hotel, I certainly got it, it was a toss up between the Penn and this, I should've went to the Penn, far superior to this hovel.
Two good points though...it is a handy central location and there is no food to get poisioning from.
Comfortable, clean value!
Like a museum, the Herald Square astounded me with it's artwork and magaizine cover displays. A very clean and comfortable hotel, with cozy rooms. I couldn't believe I got such a great hotel for under $100 per night!
No bed bugs here...
I wa alarmed by a review on this site which reported bed bugs at this hotel. I stayed in a single room with private bath in July 2002 and had no problem. In fact this hotel represented very good value at $79 a night - the room was spacious and clean. In fact much better than another hotel I stayed at in New York. Great location for shopping at Macy's too!
Life in Herald Square
Being on a tight budget, but wanting to visit N.Y.C. we searched the internet for a cheap but good hotel.We found the Herald Square Hotel highly recommended at many web sites so we tried it.Great location, very clean rooms interesting history and friendly staff.Was home to the old Life magazine and Charles Dana Gibson of Gibson girl fame.Ask for the 9th floor!
Grandma & 2 Grandaughters
We stayed @ Herald Square Hotel on advice from Friends who stayed there... The Room was Big, Bright and Clean. The staff could'nt have been more helpfull and the price was VERY inexpensive... two teenagers and me.....very comfortable
and Thanks to Ms Euginia Simons
Bed Bug Beware
I stayed at the Herald Square Hotel in May 2002. The Hotel was well located and cheap. The dingyness of the rooms was OK considering the price and they were reasonably clean. However the beding was infested with bed bugs that bit me all over and caused a hideous itchy and painful rash that lasted for more than a week.
TripAdvisor Reviews Herald Square Hotel New York City
Travel Blogs from New York City
On the 24th we took a flight from San Fran to Newark airport to begin our journey to New York for the 'holiday season'. Due to time differences, even though we left at an ungodly hour, we arrived in the big apple in the dark. Luckily for us, New York is the place that never sleeps. We headed out to see the nightlife on Christmas Eve, particularly …
Hello from Bex!
It was a surprisingly long flight from Cancun to New York and we were sad to leave Mexico which had ended up being and huge and important part of the trip. But as we took a cab from JFK into town we soon got excited! Even though I've been a few times now you never get over the view of the Manhattan skyline when you first see it. We went straight to my brother James' apartment on Avenue C where we arrived rather shell ...
... hotel. Out to dinner at Capital Grill at the Chrysler building. Very expensive. Our bill was $440 included 2 entrees, 4 steaks, 4 vege sides and 1 bottle of wine. Nice but... We then ventured further on to the Empire State Building to go to the lookout. Hundreds of people there. Took about 1 hour to get to the 86floor lookout. Had to go through security, then buy tickets, then get 2 elevators. Magic night for it. Very clear although a bit cold. Home to bed at 11.15. A big ...
... it was time to go find a suitcase. Having googled "suitcase" and "luggage" shops, I had managed to find one that happened to be near the F line, which helpful stops at Bryant Park. So off I went on the subway, and found the suitcase shop to try and find a nice suitcase for Dad that I can also use to transport all the many things I have bought back with me... I succeeded.
By this time I was quite tired, but decided to get the F train back up to ...
... remember the drive home much as I past out in the back....maagies vol, oegies toe'. Waterfall Mansion, their vision, Kate and the crew are special people and I felt very spoilt and welcome....thank you all! I awoke this morning with an almighty fright, I had slept straight through 3 alarms and needed to pack and get across town to catch my AMTRAK train to DC via Philadelphia......in just over 1 hour, oh boy! This story to follow next... Ciao for ...