How has this hotel rated in the past?
Historical Traveler Reviews Grand Hotel Mackinac Island
The best place to stay on Mackinac
Having stayed at the Grand Hotel numerous times, I have not problems highly recommending it.
Food - excellent service from the mostly Jamaican waitstaff and gourmet meals.
Rooms - great views, uniquely decorated by Carlton Varney, and always clean.
Pool is beautiful, hotel has its own hiking trails, and a huge front porch to relax on. Since the hotel charges non-guests for admission, it keeps the number of visitors from being overwhelming, though large tour groups are often at the hotel for luch.
Not every room is air conditioned, prices are expensive, and conventioners often fill the hotel. Rooms never seem to be available before the posted check-in time.
The best experience ever
We had a wonderful time. The room was basically average for the price, but service was outstanding. The food, orchestra and the harp player made us feel very special. The flowers made the hotel look like we were back in the 30th. Sitting at the porch in the evening watching the sunset was great. We felt extremely relaxed and special when we left.
A Unique and Historical Place
I have had the priviledge to stay at the beautiful Grand Hotel on 3 special occasions. If you wnat to "Step Back in Time" this is the place for you. The views are spectacular , the service top notched and the food is unbeatable. I highly recommend this Jewel of the North to anyone. A highly charming place. If I could I would visit and stay each year. I have a serious collection of Grand Hotel Memrobilla and love evry peice of it.
A Magnificent Hotel!
First I have to answer a previous review where someone stated that the Grand Hotel is pretentious and does little to make the average person feel at home. You do not stay at the Grand Hotel to be treated average.
You stay there to be treated special and have the experience for a few days to live in elegance and luxury. My recent stay at the Grand Hotel was absolutely wonderful. The decor is magnificent, the rooms are beautiful, the food is excellent, and the hotel employees do everything they can to make sure your stay is a memorable one. The fact that the hotel is located on beautiful Mackinac Island only adds to this memorable experience. You truly do feel you are transported back in time!
Not so Grand
The Grand Hotel is quite pretentious and does little to make the average person feel at home. And be advised, many of the rooms are NOT air conditioned. Despite what the management tells you, these rooms are quite hot during the day and don't cool of until very late at night, if at all. I think the Grand Hotel is overrated.
Grand Hotel--the Best!
We LOVED the Grand Hotel. We went the weekend of Lilac Festival and so got a package price for the hotel which included the five or six course dinner and breakfast. We have 3 children, (2 are teenagers) and they loved it too. The pool was large and had a huge inflatable long object in it which the kids loved trying to climb on. They had croquet and bocce ball on their gorgeous lawns too. My husband and I sat in the lobby during tea time reading a book and listening to beautiful violin and piano music. Needless to say the dinner was FANTASTIC--filet mignon with a bleu cheese tart all served impeccably by Jamaican waiters. Our room was bright and colorful and the hotel is decorated in the bright Victorian colors that make you cheerful just looking at them. We will definitely go back! We stayed one night at Mission Point but it is located so far from the town that it is very far to walk there and they had a much smaller pool although the family suite was nice and less expensive than the Grand but it didn't include dinner and a great breakfast too!
The very top of the class
If you are interested in an unusual vacation that is away from the hustle of most of the areas we see now, and if you can enjoy life without jumping in a car every few minutes, this is the place ot be. If you enjoy dressing for dinner and being treated as we feel people were treated around the turn of the Century, you will not only enjoy the Grand Hotel, but will be ready to go back many times. The Grand is just what the name emplies and is look at even on the Island as the Leader of the pack.
The rooms are not large, but are as rooms were years ago. The views are among the best and the food is excellant. The service is the best I have seen, and that is after over 30 years of travel over the midwest on my job. If you enjoy walking and riking is cabs pulled by horses, or even just renting a horse and buggy and driving yourself, it would be hard to find another place to match this.
Somewhere In Time
This is a Top notch hotel, the min you step onto the island of Mackinac , your back in time. A wonderful way to see how beautiful this hotel is, just rent Somewhere In Time, starring chris Reeves and Jane Seymour. The Grounds are full of Beautiful landscaping and flowers. The food is Outstanding. oh by the way, the above two reviews are both wrong, its niether on lake Huron or Lake Superior, its in the Straits of Mackinac which connects both lake Michigan and Lake Huron.
Wonderful hotel, beautiful grounds and views. The lack of cars makes for a great getaway.
By the way, I don't know where the other Kathy and gary were, but the Grand hotel is not on lake Superior. The hotel sits in lake Huron.
My husband and I chose the Grand Hotel for our honeymoon destination. When making our reservations, we asked about the dining area where you can have beautiful view of Lake Superior and whether we could reserve a table for one of the evenings. We were told we couldn't that they were first come first served and to just take our chances. When we got there we were seated in the middle area of the dining room and we asked our waiter if we could sit by the window. He said we could not ever sit there because the owner had to invite you or you had to be "someone". On our way out we asked to see the manager and got runaround after runaround. Mind you, these rooms are not cheap. They start around $350.00 per night and that is for a cubbyhole room. After giving up on this, we went across the street to another restaurant where the treatment was much better - in fact they set us up for dinner at a "sister" restaurant that was beyond any experience you will ever have in your life so maybe it all happened for a reason. Don Musser is the manager of the Grand Hotel and he certainly needs to brush up on his people skills. Oh yes, they also charge you to look at their hotel - you can't even pass a certain point before one of their "workers" kicks you off the property. Stay elsewhere on the island - you certainly have a large selection and you'll be treated like a human.
TripAdvisor Reviews Grand Hotel Mackinac Island
Travel Blogs from Mackinac Island
We found our beachside campsite in Hiawatha Park of Lake Michigan just ten miles or so after crossing the Mackinaw Bridge. We are on the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. Our tent is pitched, it's about 72 degrees. The girls are all wound up, so it's a good to stop and let them burn off some energy running from our campsite in the woods down the ...
... shore there were places to stop and investigate, the arch, rock totem fields, beautiful homes and shore line. Once back in town, I found a great place to have lunch, Blackened White fish sandwich. I also found the original fudge shop and picked up some fudge to share with everyone back home. After a few more purchases it was time to meet the boat for the return trip. While waiting for the boat, I had the opportunity to visit with a recent high school graduate of ...
... around, but it is such a pleasant ride it seems much shorter. There are at least 5 bike rental companies and each has a license for over 300 bikes to be out. The downtown is quaint, touristy, and has beautiful old buildings. If you want to buy a t-shirt, rent a bike, eat or drink in a pub, or buy home-made fudge you will find it here. We chose to explore the inner island on our bikes as well. It is quite hilly, but is lush and overgrown. We ...
Way behind in the blogging but here it goes...
The last leg of the summer with the owners on board brought us further west and north deeper into Lake Erie and finally Lake Huron. After meeting us back in Buffalo our next stop was a small town in New York, Dunkirk, always eager to taste the local catch the owners met a dockside fisherman who wouldn't even accept money for them to take pounds of freshwater Perch off his hands. While a bit scary ...
... yellow vette and I was demudifiying our wheels at the car wash next to the laundromat. Bud reported that the most breathtaking drive in the UP is along the coast of Lake Superior, he was disappointed that the bike route did not go there.
Later, Maura and I split up for a couple hours, I drove back a few ...