Historical Traveler Reviews of Fort Recovery Beachfront Villas Road Town
No 5-star luxury villa resort
from A TripAdvisor Member
Can only agree with the previous writer. We based our travel decision for a good part on the good reviews that this place got from others on this site but unfortunately we cannot share their view.
Althought the rooms are clean, they are far from being 'luxury villas' as advertized. Maybe naive, but we expected a free standing house on the beach for ourselves, not a studio kind of room in a larger building. Wooden floors make it noisy with people on the second floor and much to our surprise the bedroom window, facing the parking lot, was no glass window but a mesh screen! Very noisy and not very discrete...
Our package included 3 meals but we ate only 2, second time to give it another try but both times cold and overcooked. But a very kind waiter indeed, reminded me of Richard Prior. Food on the island is great, especially Pussers Landing and at the Sugar Mill hotel. (nice hotel by the way)
Staff and the owner (and staff) were not too embarrassed to have an argument in front of the guests. Once I was sent to the laundry room by Pamelah, the concierge/manager, for clean towels (none in our room) and entering the laundry room I immediately got into serious trouble with a very unfriendly staff member making it clear I had no business being there. I had to apologize, being a guest! Caribean spirit, maybe. But it felt sometimes that you as a guest were interrupting their day by being there, and we are also very low maintenance. Really.
Our package included the jeep but not fuel/insurance. Included massage was good but not very friendly, masseuse was sleeping when I came in and she walked out without saying a word when finished. Was laying there not sure what to do. And I did shower before, really.
Our opinion: Would not come back or recommend to friends. It is a 3 star location at best, if you are a little spiritual minded (yoga on the pier, looked nice), do not require good customer service and do not mind neighbor noise then book the room, but not the package, it is not worth the extra money. Cars and day trips can be organized everywhere and food is better everywhere else.. On a final positive note: the location is best on the island.
Read the owner's response
Owner's Reponse
We would like to address ourselves to the two complaints we read on tripadvisor.com. If we felt they were valid complaints we would not have done so. We generally listen to all complaints carefully, and if they seem reasonable we immediately change things and that also benefits us. If the complaints seem out of line, we wait to hear more complaints of a similar nature, evaluate it and either move to correct it or discount part of it.
The week that our guests complained about the food was our chefs two weeks off. We really believed the interim chef was good, since she came highly recommended. No one else seemed to feel something was off, but I can't vouch for her expertise, but I can for our permanent chef. She just won the C.F.A. (Caribbean Food Award) for the ten best in the Caribbean.
In view of the fact that continental breakfast as it is advertised generally consists of coffee and rolls, we really thought that we were extending ourselves by making a buffet of orange juice, homemade breads such as carrot, banana and sweet raisin bread, the usual whole wheat, white and rye bread, boiled eggs, muffins when available, tea and Colombian coffee. We encourage our guests to bring in their trays, take as much as they want and either eat at the main reception, by the sea or in their villas. We also open at 7am to accommodate divers and stay opened until 11am for our newlywed late sleepers.
The jeep IS included in the week package on a seven-day basis. How could they claim that it was not included, when they received their car on time and used it all week with no additional charges. We have records to back this up from the car rental people. Many of our guests however, stay extra days beyond the week package. If indeed they used the jeep for the additional days there would be a charge.
In many years of business this was the first time we have heard any complaints about cigarette smoke. This was a real consideration we have taken into account. We immediately asked the guests if they would prefer a villa change solving the problem and they refused.
Our towels (Ralph Lauren Towels) are freshly put into the villas every day by housekeeping. The beach towels are collected and returned to the main reception by the guests, cleaned by housekeeping as quickly as possible, and put out again.
Unfortunately, the guests that wrote these reviews we are referring too, never voiced their complaints while staying here. If they did so and there was some validity we would definitely have reacted immediately. We really try to extend ourselves to make people happy and content. We take pride in being rated as a triple diamond property by AAA, starred by Fodor's and fortunate enough for having been chosen by Discovery's Travel Channel to film our place as an example of "Casual Caribbean Luxury."
We are grateful to tripadvisor.com that you publish people's statements about how they feel about the places they stay. We do learn from unintentional mistakes we may make.
Hide the owner's response
Decent but would not return...sometimes it's the seemingly little things
from A TripAdvisor Member
Overall, Fort Recovery offers decent, clean accomodations and the location is great for exploring Tortola. The staff takes good care of the facility, the boat trip is a blast, the place attracts a variety of guests, and the view relaxes the shoulders. Travelers may want to know that the bed consists of two singles pushed together, the shower is small for a skinny person, noise is an issue unless you close your villa and crank the AC, and cigarette smoke from adjacent villas may become an issue. The food is mediocre at best (unthawed cake and bone dry noodles during dinner, bread and hard boiled eggs for breakfast day after day). But the waiter is a sweetie, especially if you speak Spanish with him. The management, who reminded us of camp directors, often seemed like they were doing us a favor by taking our thousands of dollars and allowing us to stay there (without a smile to boot). Plus, we opted for the package deal but when they cancelled part of our package due to staff unavailability they didn't even offer to credit our account (and we didn't press it). And, the package does not come with a Jeep as advertised. We really wanted to love the place and we're relatively low maintenance travelers but we would definitely not return to Fort Recovery.
Absolutely beautiful
from A TripAdvisor Member
My husband and I went to Fort Recovery to celebrate our 25th wedding anniversary in mid-February 04. What a fabulous place....clean, beautiful, friendly, intimate. Pam was there to assist whenever asked.
The boat trip was a blast....snorkeling and visiting the "Willy T". The view from our room was breathtaking...always something to see going by.
The other guests were friendly. We are planning another trip this year, and this time bringing the whole family plus some. When we did leave and took the ferry back to St. Thomas to get our plane....the site of the hotels, eateries, traffic lights, the droves of people on St.
Thomas made me long for Tortola instantly.
Fantastic Wedding and Honeymoon!
from A TripAdvisor Member
There is just not enough we can say about our stay at Fort Recovery! We chose to have our small wedding and a honeymoon on Tortola and the setting here was perfect! A quiet, secluded and romantic setting, the villas were charming and comfortably furnished. Pamelah provided endless advise and arranged countless details. The provided breakfasts and private dinners were delicious, while the staff and provided services were wonderful. All of the guests we met were friendly and the boat trip together was so fun! Honestly, the only thing we wish we could have changed was our reservation--to stay another week!! We will be back for sure!
An outstanding holiday week.
from A TripAdvisor Member
If you want to feel like a King and Queen go to Fort Recovery in Tortola. The outstanding service excelled from the moment we arrived.
The Concierge, Pamelah, welcomed us with a big smile and escorted us to our beautiful rooms with a view overlooking the water and a gorgeous sunset. The complimentary breakfast was just right to start our day with the assortment of breads and the best coffee. As a part of our package for the week we were entitled to a masssage, a manicure and pedicure, and a private snorkeling trip just for Fort Recovery guests which I loved the underwater experience, car rental included and three dinners served in our room. Yummy!! One of the highlights of our week was to be included in the Champagne toast for the new Bride and Groom who had an intimate wedding on the beach at sunset. The setting was spectacular. What more can I say except we will be back next year.
Fort Recovery and Tortola-one of our best vacations ever!
from A TripAdvisor Member
We've been to other Islands, and stayed at every kind of resort, but our vacation to Fort Recovery Beach Resort on Tortola was the best! From the moment we arrived to the beautifully landscaped grounds we felt we'd made the right choice. Our beautifully appointed villa was right on the beach with a view to Frenchman's Cay and St John. Our package included a jeep and we visited all the other beaches and resorts and are happy that we chose Fort Recovery for our vacation.
Would not return
from beardiebabe
Would never stay there again. We went with another family. Neither of us got the accomodations promised. The owners were unpleasant and not accomodating. We had five children between us and needed some laundry done, which was an amenity they claimed to offer. Their staff was not willing to do it and the owners offered no support. The rooms were bare bones and not very clean. I would not return!! Tortola, on the other hand, we loved.
Read the owner's response
Owner's Reponse
"Would Not Return Review" The public needs to know the following: They did not show up the first night of their stay they claimed due to airline difficulties. We asked them if they had recourse with the airline and they said yes I worked for the airline. We called the airline and they suggested that the customer write a letter explaining the situation. At this point they did not sign in and we let it go due to the difficulty they encountered. After several days we asked them if they had written the letter and we would be glad to call the airline for them and several more days elapsed and still no reply from the guests. At this point all the children and all the people seemed to be having a good time except for this mishap. We did everything humanly possible to help them but they kept shifting the blame from one to another amongst themselves. I made several calls to the airlines and they said they were going to issue the vouchers to the guests. I gave the guests all the information and at this point they were steadily mounting up their bill. I very nicely contacted them many times at least four and they kept saying the other one would come into pay. On the very last day, the party that made the reservation said they wanted a reduction for the nt. they did not arrive even though the airline reimbursed them for the night. Since this was no fault of ours and the airline agreed to make proper payment we see no reason why we should suffer the loss. They were very indignant after they utilized all the perks and had nine days of top notch accommodations exactly the ones they reserved. We have records to proove that we gave them the accommodations they reserved and it happens to be a first class villa featured and chosen by Discovery's Travel Channel as the most desirable place on the island. This would be the first time in 32 years if any laundry was ever refused from service. We do not allow people to do their own laundry in our laundry room. We also got an award last year for the most emaculate housekeeping on the island of Tortola by the Chamber of Commerce. We feel that their comments are biased and unreasonable. That there would be no reason to sanction a double refund.
Hide the owner's response
A wonderful experience
from A TripAdvisor Member
We recently spent our honeymoon at Fort Recovery. While it was off-season that we were there, the experience was nothing less than wonderful. The thing to remember when you come to F.R. is to not expect a huge, fancy hotel type of place. The island in general is very relaxed and sometimes you can confuse what is normal "island service" as a lack of service. The pace is totally different on the island. The villas themselves are clean, the dinners in the rooms are prepared and served professionaly. The staff is very polite and willing to assist you with anything that they can.I would recommend getting the jeep rental, it was essential for us and really cut down our costs on taxi's. I would also recommend that if you have fresh flowers in your room, to dispose of them asap. They seem to attract micro-ants.Store everything in your refrigerator and definetly get some groceries (pop, beer, wine, etc) to store in the fridge. Bring your camera and tons of file, the photo opportunites are enormous!We will definetly be back to Fort Recovery.
Not a bad recovery!
from suesun
A small personable resort. The grounds and small pool were very clean.We had the week pkg.which was a good value(although the resort's boat wasn't running for the included snorkeling trip but a Tortola ferry trip was offered instead). Great views from our second floor balcony! The three dinners at the resort were excellent! The con. breakfast needs some variety and the rooms could be a bit nicer (not luxury as advertised). Also the small beach has alot of black erchins in the shallows and a few visitors were stung. The resort's west end location was great for exploring!