Flatotel

Address: 135 West 52nd Street, New York City, New York, 10019, United States | 2 star hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.
 

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.

Location

This 2 star hotel, located in the Theater District - Times Square area of New York City, is near Radio City Music Hall Backstage Tour, New York City s Official Visitor Information Center, The Ziegfeld, and An American Craftsman.
Map this hotel

Amenities

   

Historical Traveler Reviews Flatotel New York City

Shabby, Only a Few Rooms are Renovated!

from

This hotel is completely misrepresented on Flatotel's website. It makes it seem as if all/most rooms are renovated. It's just the opposite! Of the 65 suites at Flatotel, only 8 have been renovated. The rest are big, very rundown and dirty. I've stayed in Motel 6's that are much better! The bed is the worst hotel bed I've stayed in. Do not stay at this hotel unless you are sure of getting a renovated room or suite.

And get this in writing because it seems they are playing a classic 'bait and switch.' Better yet, stay somewhere else.

Can't Go' Home' Again

from

After some research in 2002 4 couples stayed at the Flatotel in June,2002. Based on that very pleasant experience we rebooked in December 2003. Little did we know it had morphed into the hotel from hell. Principle comlaint aside from very limited service are the beds which are mattresses on boards. Park benches are more comfortable. Sunday breakfast was a mess. Coffee kept running out. Help poorly trained. Manage- ment needs a good hotel consulting firm. Was it a change of ownership that caused such a severe change? I don't know.

Back to the bed issue. When I inquired about a room with more comfortable beds I was told they are all that way. Based on my experience I would suggest people think twice or three times about staying there. The Winter bargain rates are a joke. Percs are worthless.

Fantastic Stay

from

I was in New York over Thanksgiving and stayed at the Flatotel. I stay there frequently and am quite alarmed by some of the posts that I've read on this site. I've stayed 8+ times both on business and pleasure and all of my experiences have been very possitive. Rooms are clean and you can not get better service in NY or around the world. The service elevator is a little scary but you forget about all of that when you get to your room. I will stay here for as long as I can. The hotel seems always packed with nice guests and a few celebs so I think I am not alone in my views. All I can say to those who had a negative experience, lighten up.

Oh My God!!!!!!

from

I can't even begin to describe how shabby and run down the accommodations were. We checked out. Save yourself look elsewhere! It is clear that no money is put back into this operation......

Not bad for a family

from

We spent the weekend before Thanksgiving in New York at the Flatotel. I was a bit leary after reading reviews posted at this site. However, we were pleasantly surprised. Our family of five - 2 adults, 3 children - shared a 2 bedroom suite that was spacious and comfortable. The rooms were kind of tired and worn out, but perfectly adequate. The location is great. The staff was slow, but pleasant. The place was crawling with kids. I would probably stay there again on a family trip, but opt for something a little nicer for an adults only trip.

Oh Dear

from

Myself and two colleagues stayed in hotel rooms in the Flatotel on business last week and were disappointed to say the least.

On the plus side, it was very convenient for our office and the midtown area, I like hard beds so found then very comfortable, there was Molton Brown stuff in the bathroom and the wake up call system seemed to work ok.

On the minus side though, the rooms smelt funny and musty, and for a non-smoking room, smoky. The bathrooms had not been cleaned and the (unnecessary) jacuzzi was grimy. The room design was odd with the closet in a difficult position, and the connecting doors weren't sound-proofed. The Fitness Suite was really not up to scratch with possibly the most terrifying spiral staircase in NY leading from the 46th to the 47th floor, right by the full-height windows, and the fitness equipment was old and had no instructions. Staff were surly, phone calls were laughably over-priced and overall it seemed far too expensive for what it was, even on a corporate rate.

Overall I wouldn't stay here again unless the only other option was a hostel, and even then I would have to think very carefully.

Never again

from

On the surface, has nice modern appearance. But comfort is poor - beds rock hard, room design uncomfortable with small closet in hard to reach area far from door, poor work area, bath - old jaccuzi sockets I thought not very sanitary and bathtub itself not clean, the remote control did not work and despite front desk replying that someone would bring a new one right up - it took hours.

For similar rates, you can buy much better comfort and service.

A Flat Experience!

from

The FLATOTEL, is frankly the worst hotel experience we have ever had, anywhere.The staff is totally unprofessional. They are defensive to the slightest request, like asking for hangers, since the room only had 4 hangers, for two people, staying one week. The breakfast tray arrives with a coffee carafe, 2 cups, 1 wooden stirrer, and no napkins....this was not an oversight, this was every day. It is shabby service, pretending to be a cutting edge boutique hotel which is not. If you did not know you were in New York City, you would think you were in a motel on an interstate in somewhere USA. At 3 in the afternoon trays are littering hallways as you stand in the hallways waiting for elevators that take over 5 minutes to arrive. The one positive you can say...the grey, cell-like standard room was clean. The beds are so hard, you need a chiropractor when you get home....This staff should be re-trained in the hospitality business, they stand around the lobby like maitre d' doing nothing. The most pleasant person you will run into is the salesperson in the small convenience store downstairs and the bartender, they are genuinely warm. Stay somewhere else.

Horrible experience

from

We chose the Flatotel for it's location, and after we arrived, we realized that the location was the ONLY thing good about the hotel. Except for the newly renovated Bar/Restaurant area in the lobby, we found the hotel at best dingy, and at worst, dirty. The hotel was understaffed, beat up (although they continually talked about the rooms having been renovated), and basically a huge dissappointment. I will NEVER stay at this hotel again, and hope that no one else makes the same mistake I made. Upon arrival, the desk clerk seemed to be trying to provoke me into an argument. I was able to keep the peace, and after a lengthy discussion concerning direct billing, my fiance' and I were finally able to go up to our room. The first elevator that stopped in the lobby was in horrid shape, but the bellman explained that it was the service elevator, and that we would not take it. But then, the next car that arrived looked almost as bad as the service elevator. Our room was large, and although it was supposedly "newly renovated," it was in need of a good scrubbing. There was also a hole in the dry wall in the closet. My fiance' was digusted by the condition of the bathroom, and cleaned it herself after being frustrated in her attempts to get housekeeping to answer the phone. We had dinner plans that evening, and hurried out to meet our friends. When we arrived back at the hotel at 9:00 that night, we found that a party was being held in the room next to ours. I called down to the front desk to complain, but nothing was done. After examining the lay out of our room, I realized that part of the problem was the design of our room. The connecting door into the next room was right next to our bed, and their were gaps around the door letting the sound from the next room bleed into ours. Actually, it was doing more than bleed into our room, it sounded like the people next door were standing right next to our bed as they talked.

Unrenovated Room Surprise

from

Booked a 1br suite on the internet so I could stay in a nice hotel room over my birthday weekend. THE PICTURES ON THE FLATOTEL WEBSITE ARE NOT INDICATIVE OF THE ACTUAL ROOMS. When I arrived in my room, the carpet was soiled and frayed, as was the sofa. Tiles were coming off of the batrhroom tub, no cd player, no vcr, no cotton linens and fancy duvet covers, no Sony WEGA TV, none of the things they say come standard with all rooms. I called the front desk (surely they made a mistake?), but was told the rate I booked at was for an "unrenovated" room. I booked through SRS-World Hotels which has a link to the Flatotel website which shows pictures of the different room types...so when I booked a 1BR suite, I thought I was getting what I saw on their site. WRONG. Unrenovated is one thing, dirty, scuzzy and BUSTED is another. Tiles falling off of the bathroom, jacuzzi spitting out dirt and spraying wildly in all directions, a "king" bed that was actually 2 twin beds put together (until you lay down and they slide apart). Just an overall disappointing experience. Make sure you know what kind of room you're paying for when you book your room.

TripAdvisor Reviews Flatotel New York City

3.50 of 5 stars Very Good
 

Travel Blogs from New York City

Leaving for NYC

A travel blog entry by sunny17 on Oct 25, 2014

3 photos

Checked out late and rushed to the airport. Thank goodness there were no issues with traffic, we arrived just in time to pass security. We boarded our Jet Blue flight to NYC. Upon arrival we met Maria Ciccaglioni for supper at Leguardia. We had a 6 hour layover in New York. We hadn't see Maria for 5 years. This was a trip full of reunions and fun times as we took a trip down memory ...

The Big Apple

A travel blog entry by graceandmarcus on Oct 13, 2014

1 comment, 61 photos

... York Knicks NBA pre season game against the Raptors (booked through ticketmaster $66USD). Amazing to be there, what an experience! Awesome to see Carmello Anthony playing in the flesh too! Unfortunately they lost by 5, close game they whole way. Madison Square Garden was an awesome stadium too. Also caught up with Kirsten Weir from Invercargill (sisters with Graces good friend Shelley) - such a small world!

New York - what a city, we loved it!!! Certainly clicked up a few ...

United Nations Building & Matilda the Musical

A travel blog entry by dorothystokes on Sep 10, 2014

1 comment, 22 photos

... of Korea is the 8th Sec/Gen of the UN and his term expires on 31/12/2016. Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian and Spanish are the UN official languages. The Organization can take action on a wide range of issues, and provide a forum for its 193 Member States to express their views, through the General Assembly, the Security Council, the Economic and Social Council and ...

New York City Day 4 & 5

A travel blog entry by merinika on Jul 10, 2014

3 photos

... the financial district did you know one million people come to work on this one street every day and make around a billion dollars a day with trading worldwide!! Our second to last stop was a Hudson River cruise out to see Lady Liberty. We headed out along the river and looked back on the skyline of Manhattan our guide was awesome he pointed out all the land marks and Leonardo Dicapros house which is outside the port where the Titantic was suppose to arrive in New York. We ...

"Mamma mia, here I go again..."

A travel blog entry by sam_i_am on May 19, 2014

2 comments, 27 photos

... piece of lasagna I have ever had. If you guys are ever in New York, I would totally recommend going there and asking for their specials. Trust your waiter; he has the best interests of your taste buds at heart.

We rolled back to the hotel after lunch so that we could take a nap before our Broadway show started at eight. It turned out to be a good idea because the show lasted quite a long time, and we were very tired by the end of it.

The show was ...