Brooks Hotel Edinburgh
How has this hotel rated in the past?
Photos of Brooks Hotel Edinburgh
Travelers also recommend:
- More recommendations
Historical Traveler Reviews Brooks Hotel Edinburgh
Oh dear - you have been warned!
What can I say - this was the worst hotel I have ever stayed in.
On the plus side the staff were friendly and the breakfast was ok.
However, the hotel is a bit of a way outside the city centre and situated beside a brewery which stinks out the whole area. The room was grotty and the mattress felt as if it was 100 years old. I simply could not sleep. We were on the ground floor, and could hear everything going on on the street outside. To top it all off our room was beside the laundry room with its numerous comings and goings and the world's loudest washing machine.
Don't go here!
Friendly and pleasant staff
Have just had an overnight stay at this hotel. Room a little basic but adequate for the length of time spent in it. Shower and bathroom area was small but overall spotlessly clean.
Brilliant breakfast - food excellent - served by pleasant and friendly staff.
Our twin beds were clean and comfortable although the corridor outside our room was a little noisy late at night with other guests going to bed.
I would have preferred accommodation closer to the city centre but during the Festival found I was out of luck. The Herald House Hotel came up on an internet search and I'm pleased to have found it. I can certainly recommend this hotel for a short stay in Edinburgh.
Perfect for us!
We were lucky enough to get tickets to the live 8 concert at murrayfield and this hotel was situated perfectly for us halfway between the stadium and the city centre.
Our room was nice & clean; the bathroom was small but more than adequate for a 1 night stay.
The breakfast was great.
At £50.00 I think it was excellent value for money and would stay there again
Quite nice actually
Just got back from Easter holidays and 3 nights at Herald House.
I was a bit worried after reading the reviews, but the stay was quite pleasant. The size of the room was ok, but the bathroom was quite small and narrow.
As the room was facing the main street in front of the brewery, it got a bit noisy at night, but it didn't bother us much. The staff at the reception and breakfast room were all very nice and friendly.
We would have preferred staying a bit closer to Grassmarket or Princess Street, the situation of this hotel was a bit "far out". The selection of pubs and restaturants nearby was poor. The only really negative thing to say about this hotel was that the double-bed was a disaster, with a terrible mattress and only one blanket to share.
If you're on a budget holiday and the price offer is right I can recommend the Herald House. But I will pick a hotel closer to the city centre on my next visit.
Skankiest hotel ever !!!!!!!!
Oh my god!!! how did we end up at this hotel. Impossible to find. Not near to the city centre at all. Pretty average area. Rooms were poorly decorated and the shower was held on by elastoplast. Dirty tiles in the bathroom and dodgy smell. Nothing like the classy looking hotel on the website. Our advice is not to go to this hotel.
We couldn't have asked for more friendly service...
I chose this hotel purely by chance when looking for enough rooms to accomodate myself and 9 friends. On arrival we found the staff to be nothing but polite ane helpful, no matter how much we pestered them! I would definitely recommend this hotel for price, cleanliness and especially service. We all had a wonderful time in Edinburgh and vowed to come again. The fact that we had only good things to say about the accomodation was a great part of this. Also, Gerry the receptionist was very cute!
Night and day rooms
We have the luxury of reviewing this hotel after having stayed in two different rooms on two seperate occasions.
On the first, the room overlooked the McEwan beer brewery (and sported the beer stink to prove it.) The room was small, but the bathroom was downright microscopic. It was so small that they had move the faucet out of the bathroom and into an alcove in the room! The bathroom was about 3 feet wide and 10 feet in length, and the toilet was positioned perpendicularly which causes problems, e.g. the lady I was with, who is 5-foot 4-inches, was banging her knees against the opposite wall when on the throne!
The shower was so small that we were constantly hitting our elbows and knees on the rather mildew-y walls (reporting this to the staff had no effect.) The shower was a contortionist's dream, but our nightmare. Couple that with the proximity of the toilet to the opposite wall (and the shower) and you can't WAIT to get out of the bathroom.
The second room was about twice the size of the first, and the bathroom was actually large enough to have the shower, toilet AND sink all in one place. However, the room's curtains had a thick layer of dust at the top -- we're talking TREES of dust. If you've ever seen dust pile up you know what I mean.
The breakfast was OK and the staff was friendly and helpful, but I think we'll try other accomodations next time we're in Edinburgh.
Brilliant Little Hotel
My partner and I stayed at the Herald House Hotel and I couldn't wait to offer feedback, as I chose this hotel over another based on the review at this web site. I'm happy to advise that we had a lovely time!!
The staff were most helpful with any queries. The room was clean, neat and comfortable. The best bit was that the location is fantastic, just 10-15 minutes walk from town and if you're feeling a little tired, there's a bus stop about 1 minute away to get you into town. All this with a filling, tasty breakfast to set you up for the day.
I would definately stay there again if visiting Edinburgh!
Fantastic friendly place
Family stayed here and thorougly recommended it. Staff were very friendly and happy to answer all queries. Disagree with above comments on breakfast, lots to eat and served very quickly.
Pity about the breakfast
Cheap but cheerfull hotel, good location but some rooms overlook the brewery. Room was small but at the price okay. could not sit on the john as it was against the shower and the wall, no leg room either side or in front.
Pity about the Breakfast. It was advertised as a full scottish but was a half english. No dumplings, fruit pudding, black pudding or the like.
TripAdvisor Reviews Brooks Hotel Edinburgh
Travel Blogs from Edinburgh
... last time I was in Edinburgh, I wasn't too impressed. It was dark, gloomy, and felt very depressing. We weren't in the city very long because we were doing a lot of day trips to begin with. Being back now though, the city is really growing on me. If you can get used to walking up hill for nearly everything you need, and the grey colour everywhere you go, then this city could be a great home. Perhaps I will find myself back here some day.
... isn't far, just 5 or so miles. It doesn't smell like our ocean cities. My guess is that the lack of surf keeps the salt smell from churning up. Berries grow wild in the small city parks, blackberries and some other kinds that I wasn't sure of. Maybe raspberries, but they looked too big. We got to the hotel and took a small walk to get our bearings. Then we cleaned up to go to dinner at a local Indian restaurant and the concierge suggested a pub just around ...
Here I am up at 3am local time. It is 8pm back in Utah. I should be sleeping right now, and could if I just let myself lie down. But I am restless. I am already feeling a little homesick. At times I question whether I will be able to meet this challenge that I have placed before me. It is a challenge, but I intent to rise to it. I have set my mind on making this the ...
... to go. What a beautiful looking course. It is just so green and the fairways are undulating, but seem wide enough but are bordered by long, thick heather and grass etc. There are lots of bunkers, hugely deep bunkers.
After watching three or four groups, mostly with Club-provided caddies, if is time to go back and head off to Edinburgh.
The times just flys and it already 2.00pm. The trip to Edinburgh however is only about 75 ...
The rest of the day we had a pretty chilled out day in
preparation for the New Years Eve celebrations; purchasing food and our BYO
drinks for the event.
We arranged to join Ciaran, Nate, Alex and
his mates in our hostel common area for pre-drinks pre- attending the Hogmanay
Street Party, literally right outside our hostel!
The street party consists of thousands ...