Bonnie Castle Resort

Address: 31 Holland Street, Alexandria Bay, New York, 13607, United States | 3 star hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.


This 3 star hotel, located on 31 Holland Street, Alexandria Bay, is near Boldt Castle and Yacht House, Thousand Islands, Wellesley Island, and Heart Island.
Map this hotel



    Historical Traveler Reviews Bonnie Castle Resort Alexandria Bay

    Wonderful weekend!


    My husband & I stayed at Bonnie Castle on Columbus Weekend. Our room was clean & well kept. The staff was terrific! The restaurant has the most wonderful food and the bar was fun. This is an older resort...some repairs should be made, but I think the price, the views, the food and the staff made it at steal! We will definitely stay there again.

    Read reviews before you go....


    I just return from a weeks stay at the Bonnie Castle. I read the review before I went and glad that I did. The room they gave us was not that clean and we could not open the air conditioner vent due to the age. I had mentioned this to the head of our group. He stated that we were to all be together and I should not have had that room. I went back and they gave me another room and acted like it was a hardship. The people across from me never got their ac working. This is a beautiful area...resort has many meanings to different people. This is an older area and does need some maintance. The food was excellent in the dining room. The pool and hot tub were okay. They have their own boat to go to Boldt Castle which was very nice. You can walk down to the shopping areas. A lot of the shops had closed down for the season but the ones left open are nice. Susan and her staff were very nice and helpful. I would go back again but make sure to check your room first.

    Bonnie Castle area is prettier than the post cards and very relaxing.

    I feel good !


    Right from the start I was treated well. The courteous staff put us on the right foot starting with the reservations. The meals were delightful and the prices and portions were fair. I would do it again. Bill

    Absolutely Terrible


    We stayed at Bonnie Castle Resort last night. This is not a resort!!!

    The rooms were terrible - filthy, no alarm clock. TV from the 70's - 19 inch if that. No PS or Nintendo or Movies available on the tv. Our room did have a vcr that they offered to rent movies to you for. We had water stains all over everything & dried on food on the "desk". Air Conditioner didn't work & couldn't open the windows because they had no screens. Kids enjoyed the indoor pool - would have been a great view if the windows ever got washed & you could see through them - the ones that were'nt broken & boarded up. Alex Bay is a great place - I've been there dozens of times and this is the only hotel in the area that I have not been 100% pleased with. Make the trip, just don't stay here.

    Place needs repairs just to make it acceptable


    The web site is totally misleading. The buildings and grounds are a disgrace. The owner should stick to fixing up the place instead of adding more properties. It is only a matter of time this place will fall apart

    Choose another hotel at A Bay


    This is not my first choice to stay in A Bay. The rooms are adequate at best. My sister-in-law was charged top dollar and when she entered the room there was scrambled eggs behind the door on the shag rug. The front desk was ambivalent.

    I have rented a slip from them and this seems to be o.k....However be warned that you must bring your own towels if you utilize the shower.

    Barely adequate for a very short stay..


    Room accomodations are adequate. Brochure and website are totally misleading. This not a Resort Hotel by any stretch of the imagination. The property is shabby, we ate elsewhere as the dining room smelled. The pool is in the middle of the parking lot and poorly maintained. The gift shop is the size of a large closet.

    Absolutely disgusting


    We were in Alexandria Bay for a martial arts hall of fame banquet and tournament earlier this month and all of our party was to stay at the castle. After smelling the lobby and the uninformed staff we took the liberty of viewing our rooms. Oh my god I wish this was a "smell a review" It stunk so bad and was filthy. The pull out sofa had something vile squirted all over it and when I had called ahead to see if they would put an iron and ironing board in our room it turned out to be one of those table top ones that had a cover on it that was all shreaded. One of our other party said the room he was shown had a huge rip in the carpet all the length of the room. If we had stayed there we would have had to burn our clothes it smelled so bad. The food at the banquet was adequate but there was no offer of any beverage other that water and coffee and that we had to ask for. We had to pay for tea and soda. The recreation facility should have been condemned a few years ago and do the words broom and soap and water mean anything. We all ended up staying at the Pine Tree Resort and it is cute and quaint with a lovely staff. A little worn but just enough to give it character. We had prompt service and comfortable accomodations. I would stay there everytime I went up and our entire party agreed.

    Peaceful & Beautiful


    The setting at Bonnie Castle Resort is, I think, the most tranquil & beautiful of all the hotels. We had a great room right near the water right across from Bolt Castle. Can't wait to go back!

    Great Restaurant


    Bonnie Castle has a great restaurant with a lovely view and great food. The resort has lots going for it but if you are looking for a room that overlooks the water you might try somewhere else. Very few rooms have a water view or balcony close to the water.

    TripAdvisor Reviews Bonnie Castle Resort Alexandria Bay

    3.50 of 5 stars Very Good

    Travel Blogs from Alexandria Bay

    On the road agian

    A travel blog entry by 73magicbus on Sep 26, 2015

    4 photos

    ... as we head west.

    The drive was typical of southern Ontario. Lots of open land with corn fields going for miles. The small towns that make up the cross roads are plentiful. We decided to stop at one called Merrickville. It had a eclectic selection of country stores selling crafts, fudge, ice cream and knitted goods, you know the typical country general store. We walked along the street and poked our way thru the interesting ones. The only thing we purchased ...

    Lake Placid NY ,Tupper Lake ,Watertown , 1000Is Ca

    A travel blog entry by ronstaz on Sep 25, 2015

    Left scenic Whiteface Mt to Lake Placid to tour the Olympic Ski Jump facilities Drove scenic Olympic Hwy 3 to Busy old Watertown for fuel Continued to Canadian border bought duty free & camped at expensive KOA camp at 1000 Islands camp at $75 Last night in Motorhome Great trip but too much driving draining as only driver Vowed last van ...

    Danville , Montpellier ,Burlington ,Charlotte,Lake

    A travel blog entry by ronstaz on Sep 24, 2015

    Left beautiful Danville camp to grubby Montpellier for info then to Bypass Burlington to Charlotte ferry to Essex NY over Lake Champkain Drove onto Lake Placid $ walked the Olympic Ski village Lousy Italian lunch & poor info service Camped at pine forest KOA Whiteface ...

    Day 89-91 - a Bridge and a Castle

    A travel blog entry by photokent on Aug 19, 2014

    1 comment, 10 photos

    ... but it is Sunday afternoon so we guessed that vacancies will be available. Numerous other campers were checking in, and I make my way to the front desk. "Yes", I am told, "there are several sites I available with electrical hookup". He gives me a map with the potential sites and says, "select two sites and come back to register". This is in case one of the two sites gets sold before I return. Interesting concept, no doubt born of experience. We ...

    Day 46

    A travel blog entry by sarrdh on Sep 01, 2013

    6 photos

    ... a little store selling antiques and hand made items. Sara spots a carved wool serving stand and is surprised to see its a music box! This treasure finds its way into the travel bag... See we have room... We take an opportunity for a photo op and send a picture of the Chief to Florida to one of the locals' brothers near Orlando. She was extatic. Our destination today is Mark's uncle's Farm in Gouverneur, NY. We arrive mid- day and the catching up ...