Ameritania Hotel

Address: 230 West 54th Street, New York City, New York, 10019, United States | 2 star hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.
 

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.

Location

This 2 star hotel, located in the Midtown area of New York City, is near The Late Show with David Letterman, Gershwin Theater, Roseland Ballroom, and Ed Sullivan Theater.
Map this hotel

Amenities

       

    Historical Traveler Reviews Ameritania Hotel New York City

    HORRIBLE

    from

    First off the Hotel was NOTHING like what the Expedia.com review claimed. The lobby was nice, but the room was horrible. TINY (Even by NY standards), smelly, and noisy. It was barely lit, gloomy, had a beat up old air conditioner, and the wallpaper was peeling at all of the seams. I had requested a queen bed, but when we checked in we were given a double. A chat with the clerk at the desk and we were informed that because we booked through Expedia, a queen was requested, but not guaranteed. After scanning my itinerary I found the small print which said so. How cute. Fine, we'll keep the stinky, stuffy cramped double-bed room. Well, to my surprise, when we tried to sleep that night, we got to listen to the elevator all night. It was like a sound effect of someone dragging furniture around on the floor right above ALL NIGHT. Well, after a non-existant night of sleep, I squeezed into the closet sized bathroom, and climbed over the toilet to get into the shower the next morning. Oh joy, a light drizzle of water coming out of the showerhead! How invigorating! At least the dribbling shower was hot...The only positive thing I can say about the room. The shower curtain did not fit the shower correctly, so the closet sized bathroom floor flooded during every shower. The second night was more of the same, but just to top things off, the air conditioner started sounding like a blender filled with rocks. (Since the windows didn't open at all, the only way to get any fresh air into the musty room was with the air conditioner.) NOT the renovated art-deco the Expedia review claimed.Done with Ameritania, and done with Expedia.

    Ameritania is hip and a great value

    from

    I just popped off to NYC with a couple of girlfriends for the weekend and decided to stay at the Ameritania because of its central location (right next to the Ed Sullivan theater). Our large-ish room, with two double beds, immense closet and well-appointed bathroom were ideal. The decor was modern, yet managed to be cozy, too. We enjoyed the Twist Lounge in the lobby as a good place to hit before stepping out. The free bagel/coffee/juice breakfasts in the morning were also a nice touch. We would definitely consider staying there again, if we don't check out one of their sister properties, the Moderne or the Bentley. Perhaps the naysayers stayed prior to the renovation? Check it out!

    Very small and basic but it did the job!

    from

    well the best thing about this hotel is its ideal location..right in the heart of times square, next to the letterman show. we chose this hotel because of the reasonable price and because it looked modern and clean. there were 4 of us in our room with 2 double beds, but it is true what they say...the rooms were tiny, with not much room to manouver. reception area is very modern, with a cosy fireside bar. However the rooms were not modern and as i say very small. i would probably not go back to this hotel as the room was just far too small, but we had a great time in new york anyway.

    Shoe box room

    from

    The Hotel was nice but the room was so small it was hard to walk around. And the shower only had half a door so when you take a shower the bathroom gets flooded. Also the bathroom had no fan so I felt faint after a hot shower. Great location but crappy room.

    Front Desk needs help

    from

    My sister and I received good reviews from persons who had stayed at the Ameritania in NYC.

    Anticipated decor - arrived 12/26/02 at front desk about 4pm - great doormen-helpful-front desk quickly handled our reservation and key - opened the door to the room to find 1 double bed - when reservation clearly states 2 double beds or 1 king.

    called desk - "that's not our problem" - "you have what you reserved!" explained what we paid for - "sorry that is all I can do!" - called HDN - got to a supervisor - told he would call hotel and get problem cleared - 30 minutes later and 4 phone calls to desk and HDN -a bellman at the door to move us 2 rooms down to 208- great 2 double beds-everthing is fine - no heat but were not advised of radiator operation. 2nd floor is very noisy - bar #54 is loud until about 1 or 2 am. Morning found a major leak from the bath ceiling and tub area. Advised desk - no response for 4 hours - out sightseeing -not repaired until 2nd call - maid cleaned room but left no clean towels. following dinner and show - had to call again for towels. 2nd day our plastic card cards would not open the room - very rude front desk said that both cards were not working due to our putting the cards in our wallets - where would one keep the key cards was our question? She shrugged and reminded us as you would a child to take care of the key cards. She probably assumed we had never seen such keycards - oh! my! it's the big city!

    Spouse called the hotel on 12/27 and was told that we were not registered - we had checked in 12/26. He called back after cell phone call to me - confirming our presence and insisted when he again called the hotel - it seems we were there this time! Upon attempting to partake of the FREE BREAKFAST SERVED FROM 7 -10 - at 9:20 arrived to find only juice and coffee - no bagels - no food- just coffee and juice. Attendant reminded us that it was 9:20 - all food was gone! Does 7 - 10 really mean 7-9:20? Check out day 12/29 arrived - we had a great time in NYC - we chose not to let the bad hotel experience ruin our trip - we have seen worse but most of the time seen a lot better - even the modest Holiday Inn maintain cordial staff. Hotel is in a great location - we elected to go for location -never expecting a hotel in such a location would be of this low caliber. We were prepared for the furnishings - older hotel- and all the premise problems - but no excuse for rude front desk - and poor management to detail. We were treated kindly by police, subway personnel, theatre personnel, merchants, dining staff at very busy restaurants - and expected vendors - but to have such hotel staffed at a front desk with such rude and uncalled for behavior is a shame. I am proud of New York - the whole country is pulling for New York - we want to see New York proper with all the past and current problems - we who live in other areas of the country believed your former mayor that New York wants us to visit NYC. The city has more to offer than most any major city in the US! Why don't the people at the Ameritania have the same attitude as the rest of the city. If you don't like your job - make a change - be happy in what you do and how you project the image of your hotel. Don't mess up something that could be so positive. Bad impressions usually have a life of their own - they tend to grow. The Ameritania front desk staff can change - you can make the difference - why not be known as the nicest moderate hotel in NYC - the ch

    ritania!

    Worst hotel in NYC

    from

    My husband and my two children stayed at the Ameritania on 12/6/02. The hotel staff were rude and had no idea what customer service meant. They gave a room with a king size bed and could not get a roll away bed for my husband to sleep in. We could not all fit in the bed. They didn't care and said they did not have to guarentee anything because I booked the hotel through the internet, expedia.com..it was the worst hotel I have ever stayed in. never again. we asked for our money back and no one has responded. we will be writing letters.

    Doesn't live up to expectation

    from

    We have stayed at the Ameritania Hotel twice. The first time was absolutely awful. The room was very small, no amenities and the window didn't even shut all the way! The second time (we went a second time b/c it was on the Thanksgiving parade route), the room was on a higher floor and was a bigger, much nicer room. Still, it would be nice to have some comfortable chairs in the room. Both times the noise was unbearable. I have lived in Manhattan, so I am accustomed to the usual noises that go on. However, this was beyond anything acceptable for a hotel. There seemed to be a nightclub or concert hall very close to the hotel. We could actually feel the bass while we were lying in bed! This is an ok hotel if you want to be close to Times Square and you are going to be partying all night. Otherwise, find something a little more comfortable.

    Glitzy cover, bad story

    from

    The purportedly all-renovated hotel got a facelift in the lobby, the pictures of rooms looked elegant, but the 'real' rooms we got were musty, cramped and extremely noisy. They evidently forgot to change the 100-year-old windows. Even with a room change from the noisy Broadway side on Friday night to the equally noisy street side on Saturday night, the noise was unbearable. We were there for the Revlon run, and got very little sleep, no thanks to Ameritana.

    Ameritania Hotel - great place, we loved it

    from

    We loved staying at the Ameritania. We had a medium-sized room with a walk-in closet and marble bathroom. Plus you walk outside and you're at the tip of Times Square, lots of bistros etc nearby. And Letterman if you like.

    Worse hotel in new york

    from

    outside and lobby look alright but rooms are boxes, dirty, grubby decor and furnishings out of the ark.had to change first room because room dirty with loose floor boards.disappointing and thankfully only stayed a couple of days.

    TripAdvisor Reviews Ameritania Hotel New York City

    4.50 of 5 stars Outstanding
     

    Travel Blogs from New York City

    All I want for Christmas is to get out of this cab

    A travel blog entry by nikiandthomas on Jun 27, 2014

    38 photos

    ... did I know I had just got into an illegal taxi cab. Once the car was moving I checked that I could pay on credit as you can in all taxis out here and he told me that I couldn’t and the fare was $75 cash. A normal taxi is about $60ish so it was only a little bit more but this guy was saying it was $75 each. He was going to make a fortune out of us all. With no cash on me I rung Thomas to ask him to withdraw some and meet ...

    Day 11 Monday

    A travel blog entry by jo4644 on Apr 07, 2014

    1 comment, 34 photos

    Today was all about walking, food and skateboard shops. We caught the train to Borough Hall and started down Court St, passing a grand old building on the way (maybe the Supreme Court?). First stop was Trader Joes to get a $1 souvenir shopping bag. I was also tempted by the mini milk chocolate peanut butter cups but as there is already about 7 different types of peanut butter candy in the suitcase I passed. Across the road was Bareburger, an organic hamburger ...

    Helpful Advice On Losing Weight And Keeping It Off

    A travel blog entry by skaabelibg on Mar 27, 2014

    ... of the elevator, even if just a few stories you are climbing.

    You definitely want to be monitoring your caloric intake if you plan to lose weight. Burning more calories than what you eat is going to result in weight loss. Eating fiber-filled foods will reduce your feelings of hunger. Drinking lots of water will also reduce your hunger pangs.

    Carefully monitor you beverage choices when attempting to ...

    Making The Most Of Your Jewelry Collection

    A travel blog entry by renninejgh on Mar 27, 2014

    ... piece has a different meaning and should be given or worn in a specific context. There is a plethora of information to absorb and it could be difficult to apply it to your daily life. The best tips you can get are here; read them right here.

    Don't clean your jewelry in harsh household chemicals like ammonia, bleach or turpentine. Doing so can damage the shine and luster of the stones on your favorite pieces.

    Do some ...

    New York City. Where your dreams come true.

    A travel blog entry by yana.k on Sep 23, 2005

    18 photos

    ... to party with my girlfriends from work and my oh-so-helpful ID. Manhattan's 26th to 29th street between 9th and 10th ave was full of nightclubs. Stereo nightclub with DJ AM before he got extremely famous, QUO ( i still don't know what that means), Pink Elephant, Crobar, Marquee, some other places like Avalon (club inside of gothic old church), Plumm and club AER - we've seen them all. Great music, a separate table with drinks, always ...