Amara Cay Resort

Address: 80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida Keys, Florida, 33036-3802, United States | 2 star hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.


This 2 star hotel, located on 80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, is near Anne's Beach, Key Dives, Bud n' Mary's Sportfishing Marina, and Indian Key State Historic Site.
Map this hotel


Photos of Amara Cay Resort


          TravelPod Member ReviewsAmara Cay Resort Islamorada

          Reviewed by nealyhl

          Good value

          Reviewed Apr 16, 2010
          by (1 review) Jacksonville , United States Flag of United States

          The hotel and staff were great. It was nice as a starting point to travel up and down the keys. It was not too bad of a drive to get back to Miami for return flight. Definitely recommend.

          This review is the subjective opinion of a TravelPod member and not of

          Historical Traveler Reviews Amara Cay Resort Islamorada

          Nice enough


          We stayed here over Easter 2004 and found the rooms to be surprisingly spacious and the staff friendly. Breakfast was ample and included as it is at all Hamptons. My only complaint with the hotel was the room price seemed pretty steep - but I think that would be true anywhere in the Keys during the Easter holidays.

          One caution, we don't recommend the dive outfit (Key Dives) a hundred yards away by the bridge. Their boat was old, smelly and bounced in the waves. I think you could do better.

          Terrible experience!!!!


          A few years ago we stopped in without a reservation. My wife negotiated a decent deal with a gal working at the front desk. The owner over heard the "discounted price" and blew up. Screamed at the employee, told us to get the "F" out. I nearly decked him, but didn't want to end up in jail. I used to travel for a living and have NEVER been treated so badly. My advice, stay away!!! A year or so after the incident I read that his roof got destroyed by a hurricane, there is justice. (I hope no one was hurt)

          Two thumbs up for the Islamorada Hampton Inn!


          My family totally enjoyed this Hampton Inn.

          I had gotten a great rate via their internet website, and was actually surprised when they put us in a one bedroom suite. Upon entering the suite, you're in a livingroom area w/pull-out couch, coffee table, chair. There is a bar area w/stools and a full kitchen, including a dishwasher & microwave. Kids were psyched to find there was a VCR & they could order up an hour of Nintendo. Sliding glass doors off both livingroom & bedroom, with views of both the bay and the ocean.

          The deluxe continental b'fast was excellent. There were hard boiled eggs, several bagels, yogurt, cereal, danish, several juices, & coffee. Also, they put out coffee and cookies each afternoon.

          The pool was nice, there is also a beach area w/lounge chairs for sunning, and a tiki bar as well. We were able to check in a bit early ~ everyone working here that we came into contact with was pleasant & nice. This Hampton was also very clean ~ from the hallways to the public bathroom near the pool. This place more than met our expectations and we would definitely return!

          Nice Enough


          I would venture to say that this is probably one of the nicest places to stay in Islamorada. After looking over the area, most hotels and motels seem overly worn. But this one is in above average shape by comparison. It was completely renovated 7 years ago (according to the manager). The rooms are decent, the lobby is nice. The pool and pool area are in good shape. The only negative thing I would mention is that the beach is for tanning only because it is raised and not ocean-level (you probably wouldn't want to swim in the ocean here anyway). The free breakfast is a great perk as well as the free afternoon coffee and cookies. Overall, I would recommend staying here.

          Nice Place


          This is a perfectly nice hotel. Not extremely fancy, but very decent with nice rooms, people, pool and lounge area. We paid $170 per night, but this is doing pretty good for the area, especially if you want to stay somewhere that is not run down. We went to the Hampton after first going to Holiday Isle. Run, don't walk to the Hampton. Holiday Isle was dirty, expensive, run down and the room looked like a flop house - also the people are very rude! Strongly recommend the Hampton.

          Best place to stay in Islamorada


          Great place to stay. Rooms and public areas were very clean. Request room over pool or ocean view. The staff are very nice and helpful. You will like the breakfast. Great place for one or two night stay. I will stay here again. I've stayed in many places on Islamorada, including Cheeca Lodge, and I like this place the most.

          Be CAREFUL!


          While the rooms here were very nice (better than the 5-star Westin just up the road!), we had a dismal experience with the staff among other things. (FYI - I'm not one of the flame throwers typical these boards - I really try to fairly appraise most things - these things really happened, judge for yourself.)

          (a) I got chigger bites from the bed in the hotel room (b) We booked back in March, and when we arrived the pool was out of commission for re-surfacing. They could have easily called and told us. The replacement was the "Breezy Palms" next door - which we renamed the "Greasy Palms" for the cleanliness of the pool. When we were told about the pool the staff could not estimate the distance to the nearby property in yards, miles, or furlongs. Distance is not their strong suit. (c) We wanted to go to the Theater of the Sea, and asked the front desk how much a cab would be to get back. They had no idea (about $10 FYI). (d) When we made our reservation the staff fat fingered the month and had us coming in a month early. So I got billed as a no show on my credit card. I called to correct it, and the person made it right by doing the best she could in terms of rooms and price. Crisis averted, or so I thought. This person (we'll call her Gertrude) also fat fingered the date and we were billed AGAIN as a no show. When I called to try to work it out, Gertrude insisted that she had not made a mistake - and did not offer to make it right. I spoke to the manager who insisted that Gertrude was one of her top people, had been working there three years, and never makes mistakes. He offered to make it right, but not without some expressed discontent - no "I'm so sorry sir, blah, blah, blah" - just an insistance that Gertrude never makes mistakes. I wanted to say that "I've been booking hotel rooms for more years than Gertrude's been alive and I've NEVER MADE ONE mistake before let alone TWO on a reservation." The kicker was when I went to check out they STILL tried to charge me for the wrong nights. In the end, I paid the right price, but WATCH YOUR BILL. (d) There was an unsavory smell on the third floor as you get off the elevator (e) There is NO view (unless you like power transformers) on the side of the hotel that overlooks the parking lot - get one overlooking the pool. (f) don't come hoping to get a gentle beach that slopes into the water. It's a cement seawall with steps. The water is a little iffy right at the hotel too. It was actually better to go in at the "Greasy Palms" next door to walk out to the sand bar.

          I'm sure that if you double confirm your reservation and get a room overlooking the pool, you'll have a great time. It's a nice way point between Miami and Key West. The breakfast was great; I'm sure the pool is nice when it's operating. Don't expect too much from the staff or Gertrude or the General Manager and you'll be fine.

          Very nice property


          Spent one night here in February 2003. Rooms were dependably Hampton Inn-very clean, basic but nice furnishings with balconies.Property was defintely more than I expected! A small but lovely beach area with a big hammock, Adirondack chairs, beach lounge chairs, and a tiki bar and restaurant. There is also a good size pool overlooking the ocean.Located at MM80 with many choices ot restaurants and bars within a few mile radius of the hotel.

          Cant get any better


          every thing about the hotel is great, it's worth the extra money to stay here

          What a Great Place to Stay!


          We only had one night to spend at this lovely inn. We had a one bedroom suite overlooking the ocean and it was gorgeous! average size balcony with chairs to enjoy the sunrise and sunset, overlooking a private beach and dock area. I would suggest getting a room overlooking the ocean, or any room on the north or south side near the ocean end of the hotel.

          Breakfast was fantastic. Lots to choose from and always being filled when stocks ran low. I would suggest this hotel to anyone. I live in a tourist area of southeast Florida and know a good place when I see it.... and this is IT! We plan on going back throughout the year and will definitely stay at this hotel/inn.

          TripAdvisor Reviews Amara Cay Resort Islamorada

          4.00 of 5 stars Excellent

          Travel Blogs from Islamorada

          Southern Winds

          A travel blog entry by ninapennewell on Apr 15, 2014

          5 comments, 42 photos

          ... We had to fuel at one marina and then dock at another. Moreover, we seemed to have chosen the worst fuel dock ever. It was basically self service although they would help you tie up if you called ahead for help. And to give them credit, they did tie us up. Unfortunately, after they tied us they immediately deserted us and we could not open our door because they had tied the rope over the it. So we had to radio them again and ask for assistance with fueling. They came and handed ...

          Lots of Critters

          A travel blog entry by ralphieboyo on Mar 07, 2013


          ... of Crane. They developed it as a Nature Center etcetera. A foundation purchased it in about 1995 for $1.3 mil.

          The area contains several trails through the jungle there. Many are not well developed, which gives you an idea of what it must have been like in the early days. We walked to George's original homesite and then on to the bird center. Here they accept injured birds and ...

          Marathon, NY

          A travel blog entry by resmucker on Jul 01, 2012

          ... Amish sitting on porch of large double house ; Barb apologized to them for intrrupting their afternoon; not too talkative. Continued driving then thought we might have found site of original settlement -- three farms next to/across from each other. Four buggies at one farm. Then headed east to Freetown, another Amish area. Stopped at Byler woodworking shop. Barb got out ...

          Sunrise, snorkelling and strippers

          A travel blog entry by williamluff on Jan 12, 2012

          32 photos

          ... we order the spicy tuna tower and red pepper conch bisque for starters followed by Tahitian chicken and pork osso bucco for mains. The food is utterly, delightfully delicious but so obscenely huge I have to push it away not even half finished.

          In the main room 'Patrick and Debra' entertain us with piano jazz. An array of standards by Sinatra, Patsy Cline, Fats Domino, Barbra Streisand, Gershwin, and Judy Garland are given the over-sincere treatment and then with much fanfare ...

          05 Everglades Winter

          A travel blog entry by tombuttle on Mar 17, 2011

          79 photos

          ... plus visited Ron and Jan; a fun weekend only tempered by lots of driving. Amanda is expecting to deliver Cindy a granddaughter in July.

          Had a great day with Moyra and Dave at the Key Largo Seafood Festival where we actually ate at Alabama Jack's. They had just returned from a ten day exotic cruise to many islands.

          Saw my first deer in both the Everglades and Big Cypress ...

          Traveler Photos Amara Cay Resort Islamorada

          Breakfast in Islamorada
          Miami Beach, United States
          Hampton Inn and Suites
          Islamorada, United States
          The Hotel's Beach
          Miami Beach, United States
          Our King Suite
          Islamorada, United States