Abingdon Guest House

Address: 21 Eighth Avenue, New York City, New York, 10014, United States | Hotel
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.
 

How has this hotel rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.

Location

This hotel, located in the Soho/Greenwich Village area of New York City, is near Photo Walk-abouts, Hotel Gansevoort Spa, Mxyplyzyk, and Boucher.
Map this hotel
   

Historical Traveler Reviews Abingdon Guest House New York City

Enjoyed staying at the Abingdon

from

I stayed at the Abingdon in May for 2 nights with a friend. The location is great, in the heart of the Village, close to everything. The room was clean and comfortable; the staff was friendly and helpful. Overall, for the price, I felt we had lucked out on a great deal. I would recommend it to friends and family.

Dont be fooled

from

by the pictures on the internet..........this place needs a serious makeover. The entrance is shabby.........with dirty worn carpets............and our room.........was cramped and dark.........with noisy air conditioning and broken window blinds................

On a brighter note........the staff........when they were there.........were helpful and friendly........but........if you are looking for comfort and luxury..........look elsewhere............sorry Abingdon...........

Nice Location, Shame about the decoration

from

We stayed at the Abingdon for 4 nights at the end of April 2005. We had two rooms - the Garden and the Martinique.

Let's talk about the Garden Room first - this room is at the back of the house on the same level as the laundry room. It has its own (small) garden and a seperate loo with small shower. It's good points are the bed which is very comfortable; a nice sofa to relax on and the quiet - the only noise we heard was people walking about upstairs. It's bad points are the lack of light (it's at basement level); the decor which is in need of some updating and the bathroom with needs modernising.

The Martinque Room is again at the back of the house, but this time on the 3rd floor. This is a nice bright room, again with its own seperate bathroom and shower. The good points about this room are the light and the 4 poster bed. The bad points are that you can almost touch the walls from either side of the bed and the mattress has a "hump" in the middle which makes getting from one side to the other "interesting".

The really good thing about the Abingdon is its location - it's in a really quiet part of Greenwich Village with a really good selection of restaurants within walking distance. The Le Bonbonierre is directly opposite and does fantastic pancakes.

Quiet is, of course, subjective, and you have to bear in mind that it does front on to Eighth Avenue. Rooms at the front are not as quiet as the 2 that we stayed in.

All in all we enjoyed our stay; if you're looking for somewhere reasonably priced and out of the chaos that is midtown then it's certainly worth considering.

Extremely noisy

from

We booked the Guest House as all the reviews we had read raved about the place. The location was perfect I agree and very close to the lovely area of Greenwich Village. However the Room (Windsor) was so noisy that it sounded as if we were sleeping in the middle of the road! The windows are so loose that you can hear every conversation from pedestrians below and being on a major thoroughfre there is no much possibility of sleep or peace and quiet.

In addition the room was dirty and poorly maintained. It was not vaccumed durng the week we were there and the bathroom wasn't cleaned properly. The duvet cover and chair covers were stained and the latter threadbare, the bathroom toiletry rack was rusty and the artificial flowers were caked in dirt. The toilet handle didn't work properly and the safe battery had run out.

After reading other reviews about the place I can hardly believe this is the same place as we stayed in. Even if it had been clean and quiet, the room was still dark and dingy and depressing.

Shabby chic is out of style

from

We booked the Abingdon Guest House for November 30, December 1 and 2, 2004 because of the reviews I had read on tripadvisor and I'm sorry to say it was a big mistake. First, our plane was late because of mechanical problems and although we continually updated Justine, she was not happy with our after-midnight arrival and showed her displeasure without a qualm. I profusely apologized for our late arrival but she was not going to be nice not matter what. As she took us up the narrow, shabby staircase, I could see the place was very shabby and in need of paint and a rehab. Our first night's room on the third floor was very small (as expected in NYC) and the bathroom was old and shabby and pieced together. The next 2 nights were spent in what was supposed to be a better room on the second floor, which although more spacious it was dirty and had way too much extraneous furniture. They seemd to be more interested in making the place "quaint" and "charming" instead of comfortable and clean. The bathroom in this room was nicer (obviously updated) but the bed was the worst! Old and very uncomfortable and the sheets had seen better days. Plus the noise, cold air, and rain came in through the gap between the window and the air conditioner. We could not wait to get out of the room each day! Each of the rooms had names but I've forgotten them. I know not to expect much on less than $200 a night in NYC but this was just thoughtless and rude. We won't go back and I hope someone tells them to update the place.

Great place to stay!

from

We stayed at the Abingdon for 4 nights Wed - Sun It was great, we loved the fact that it's in the heart of the Village and the room, the Essex was very comfortable.You don't get all the trappings of a large hotel, concierge etc, but we really liked the independant feel of the place. The place is perhaps in need of a little decoration upgrade in places, but it met our needs very well and we would stay there again.

Wish Weekends were 4 Nights Long, But....

from

Qualifier: We didn't stay here. Sorry that we couldn't experience the Abingdon, but they were firm -- a weekend booking is a minimum of four nights. If we wanted to try booking with them, we could try right before our trip and if they had a room available, they would then book a two night stay. We went somewhere else where a weekend is two nights and found a gem. Thanks, Abingdon.

Kooky bolt hole in Greenwich Village

from

I've just returned from a two week business trip, staying at the Abingdon Guest House... which was a fabulously cosy home from home. A great location, as a lone female traveller I felt totally secure and relished the freedom that the guest house provided. The Brewbar below stocks dangerously good muffins, and the friendly owners were incredibly helpful when my partner wanted to send me a surprise birthday bouquet.

The only things I would add would be a kettle and perhaps a small fridge in the room... and as a brit unused to such things, perhaps slightly quieter air conditioning!

Fantastic place to stay

from

We have just returned from a fantastic stay at the Abingdon Guest House, situated in the Greenwich Village area. This is a great place to stay - the rooms are a good size and tastefully decorated.Our host , Justine, made us feel very welcome and nothing was a hassle.The location is brilliant being situated between Soho and the Meatpacking Districts.You are surrounded by fantastic restaurants/cafes as well as speciality boutiques.The nearest subway station would probably be 5 minutes walk.This type of accomodation is ideally suited to patrons that want to use room as a base.It encourages you to go out and explore the area as close proximity to everything in beautiful surroundings.Please appreciate that this is a guest house, not a hotel.There is no room service or reception.This is a good thing as you will not be slugged stupid prices for items such as refreshments and phone charges.A Convenience store is located next door for all these needs - phone cards,snacks,drinks.My only reservation would be to recommend for people who find going up and down stairs a problem - the staircase is rather narrow and steep (no lifts) -in this case ask for the ground floor apartment.All said and done a great place in a great location.

Great location, great place!

from

We just returned from NYC and a wonderfu stay at Abingdon Guest House.

The location is EXCELLENT as its central location is about a mile or so from Times Square and SoHo/Little Italy/Chinatown. We stayed in the Garden Room and it was just wonderful. Tastefully decorated and cozy.

There are only a couple things I would change...the faucet leaked in the bathroom, the hand towel bar wasn't secure on the wall, and the bottom step (leading to our room) is in need of repair. Certainly not things that would affect your stay. I highly recommend this guest house and plan on staying there again in the future!

TripAdvisor Reviews Abingdon Guest House New York City

3.50 of 5 stars Very Good
 

Travel Blogs from New York City

I'm an English woman in New York...

A travel blog entry by nyandbackagain on Nov 09, 2014

1 comment, 23 photos

... As we entered the building I was thinking that I should have prepared myself by watching Night at the Museum where the inanimate objects I saw there yesterday come alive and have quite an adventure. But it was ok, we all know I have a great imagination. Me and the T-Rex became best buddies immediately... We didn't get to see the whole museum but we started on the 4th floor with the dinosaurs. Never have I seen (this seems to be the going phrase here ...

All of the fun tourist stuff (well, most of it)

A travel blog entry by lmules on Oct 17, 2014

6 photos

... see the Statue of Liberty, with some Taco Bell thrown in for lunch (got to be done!!). It will be our last full day, and then it's time to head home. How fast did three weeks go?! Hopefully I'll get some sleep - we have some super loud idiots talking outside our window, as well as this horrible machine that they put metal into and then crush it (right outside, starting 6am and going until late... Where is all this metal coming from?) Night night! ...

Pneumatic drills at midnight

A travel blog entry by alicebeetle on Sep 15, 2014

1 comment, 53 photos

... ceilings. Fabulous.

Madison Avenue led us through the Garment district, Flatiron District, Gramercy, Greenwich Village, Noho, Soho, Tribeca, Little Italy and Chinatown, before we hit the seaport area, and the Financial district.

We stopped off for a bite of lunch in a Mexican restaurant on Bleeker street, which was good, having sat for a while in the calm shade in Washington Square, which painter Edward Hopper used to overlook, admired the ...

Day 5

A travel blog entry by dianathor on Aug 24, 2014

11 photos

Nice surprise this morning! 8th Avenue is blocked off for a flea market - now we know what we will do between tours! Lots of neat little vendors selling jewelery, touristy stuff, purses, scarves....etc. We wandered down the street towards Central Park to catch the Green Bus to take the Harlem tour. Much to our dismay, the first tour guide with a very heavy accent was our tour guide again. We could ...

The Met ...

A travel blog entry by aspqrz on Aug 01, 2014

4 photos

... I spent a lot of time in the Egyptian Galleries ... the jewellery there is quite amazing (see the sample neck-piece), some of it's gold and semi-precious stones, a lot more is often things like alabaster or faience, and it is all both amazing and, of course, grave goods.

The gold stuff would, one way or another, all have been originally in the gift of a Pharaoh - he owned all the gold mines, and evidently kept control of ...