Andrews Inn and Garden Cottages

Address: Zero Whalton Lane or, Key West, Florida Keys, Florida, 33040, United States | B&B
Searching for availability...
*Prices above are provided by partners for one room, double occupancy and do not include all taxes and fees. Please see our partners for full details.

How has this b&b rated in the past?

  What's this?
Discover trends in hotel experiences based on real traveler reviews and ratings. Mouse over circles to see what some travelers had to say.


This B&B, located on Zero Whalton Lane or, Key West, is near Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, Key West Lighthouse and Keeper's Quarters Museum, and Western Dry Rocks.
Map this b&b


Photos of Andrews Inn and Garden Cottages

    View all photos

      TravelPod Member ReviewsAndrews Inn and Garden Cottages Key West

      Reviewed by tendashseven

      Living Like a Local

      Reviewed Mar 13, 2013
      by (18 reviews) , United States Flag of United States

      Based on a recommendation from friends, we wanted to stay at the Andrews Inn. Our stay was going to be several days and unfortunately, none of the Inn rooms had availability for the entire stay. I guess I waited too long. However, one of their cottages - the Eyebrow House - was available. We decided to splurge a bit and enjoy the extra room of a full living room, dining room, complete kitchen and back deck with a Jetted Tub. An additional surprise was our ability to use laundry facilities for free which really came in handy.

      This attractive, well-manicured and neatly landscaped cottage is located very conveniently off Duval Street. It is close to the action and centered between the two waterfront destinations. The look and feel of the neighborhood made us feel that we were residents of this quaint and wonderful destination.

      Parking could have been a challenge since the cottages do not have reserved spaces. However, the proprietor kindly reserved us a spot with his vehicle and after parking, we did not find a need to drive anywhere during our trip. We walked everywhere which helped work off the great meals we enjoyed.

      The only caution I would pass along is that the streets can become very noisy as the bars start closing or their clients reach their limits. We were frequently awakened from 1:00-4:00 AM most nights by loud voices. Of course, without thinking about it, we ended up there on a Spring Break week. So this may account for unusual nocturnal outings. Additionally, this cottage is connected to two other of the Andrews Inn cottage dwellings. If you have rambunctious neighbors upstairs or behind you, you will know it!

      The proprietors and staff were extremely helpful and friendly. As a cottage rental, we did not get to enjoy the "Breakfast" portion of the B&B. However, we did attend their afternoon happy hour and enjoyed the poolside accommodations of the main property. We would definitely stay at the Andrews Inn again - only next time, I would make my reservations much more in advance and stay at the main facility.

      This review is the subjective opinion of a TravelPod member and not of

      Historical Traveler Reviews Andrews Inn and Garden Cottages Key West

      Can't get any better than Andrews Inn


      March 28, 2006 - one week is not enough time to spend in Key West, especially if you have the privilege of staying at Andrews Inn. A quiet inn one-half block off Duval. From the minute you arrive until the minute you leave (which you'll hate doing) you are treated wonderful. The owners, Nancy & Tom, are two of the best people you can meet. They are genuinely good, good people. We were met by their property manager, Jorge, who is the most upbeat, positive thinking person I have ever met. He goes above and beyond to make your stay pleasant. Answers thousands of questions a day and always with a smile and offers great suggestions for things to do, places to eat, etc. He makes you feel like you've known him all your life and he has a great sense of humor. The inn offers a very nice breakfast, and a fun cocktail hour. A big plus as you get to meet everyone staying at the inn. Really fun! The rooms are very nice, clean and well-maintained. The roosters crowing at 4:19 a.m. every morning can be resolved with ear plugs that Jorge so graciously offers. The caretaker/room cleaner/breakfast setter upper, Luc, is also a plus to this wonderful inn. He is quiet, but very interesting to chat with in the mornings.

      Always amazing!!


      My husband and I continue to frequent the Andrews Inn. We will only stay here in Key West...we are totally loyal! The staff is unmatched and the inn is just so perfect. They do a nice happy hour, a great breakfast on the deck, and they will do anything to help you have a wonderful vacation. There are not enough things we can say about the wonderful job they do. All of the rooms are done nicely and are very cute. The privacy is great in any of the main rooms and definitely at the cottages. Everything is in walking distance and the staff will help you book any excursion you'd like to do or even any reservations for dinner you need. It was affordable and we will not stay anywhere else...we are there for life when we visit. My family had a place on Key West so I feel like I have been exposed to many different lodging options, but this is so much more. This place is a vacation in itself and how you are supposed to enjoy the island. A MUST in Key West...this is how it is supposed to be on a trip down there!

      I hated to leave


      This was my sixth visit to Key West and my fifth to the Andrews Inn. I have stayed in several rooms and cottages and always find them exceptionally clean and comfortable. Five friends stayed in the Sailor House which is a small Conch Cottage a short ways away from the B&B, but still located right off Duval on a quiet street. 2 bedrooms, 1 1/2 baths with a private deck and hot tub. Full kitchen, and living/dining area. We could not have ask for a more gracious concierge than Jorge. And Blanche and Martin kept our little piece of paradise super clean for 4 days. They continue to impress with their professionalism and great smiles. I am already planning my next trip in November and plan to visit at least yearly, for as long as possible. Lovely, Lovely, place.

      We felt at home at the Andrews Inn


      My husband and I stayed for a week during the winter holidays. The concierge, Jorge, took great care of us and we had a wonderful time. The inn is right near the Truman and Duval intersection, so you are close to everything, but it is down a little alley, so you don't have the noise from the street and it feels nice and private.

      There were a lot of little extras that made a big difference during our stay. We especially enjoyed the daily happy hour and the free use of the hotel bicycles. Jorge reminded us about the need to make reservations for New Year's Eve dinner and helped us get everything arranged.

      Our room, the Pamplona, was beautiful and had a view of the Hemingway estate from the private balcony. We will definitely return!

      Very Nice Place to Stay!


      My husband and I stayed in their Treetop Studio for 7 nights 12/6 - 12/13. This studio is the upper floor of Eyebrow House and is very private with it's own kitchen, bathroom, and deck with two-person hot tub. This unit does not receive the complimentary breakfast, and we did not use the pool although it did look nice and clean. We absolutely loved the owner and Jorge, who were instrumental in helping us make decisions on what to do while in Key West. The location couldn't be more ideal... It's within walking distance to EVERYTHING yet just a little off Duval to make it quiet.

      If you want a clean, quiet, and affordable place to stay, check them out!

      Charming and quiet oasis


      My mom, sister and I stayed at the Andrews Inn for a four day Key West get-away. We found the Andrews Inn to be a friendly, charming, peaceful place to stay with clean, tastefully decorated rooms and a helpful, upbeat staff. Can't beat the location for exploring anything and everything in Old Town. Enjoyed the resident cats in the courtyard and the mimosas for breakfast. This is a great little place!

      This place is perfect!


      The Andrews' Inn is a pretty and peaceful hideaway in the heart of all that is Key West. George was a gracious host and advised us on the best use of our time during our short stay (3 days, 2 nights). This was our first visit to Key West, but our experience was so positive, we will return! The staff at the Andrews' was primarily responsible for this good time, including our new friend, Blanche. Our room was "Venezia". It was small but charming and spotlessly clean. The Hemingway felines greeted us each morning as we enjoyed mimosas at breakfast. We had convenient parking for our car and never used it during our stay.

      Great place, super people


      Just returned from a week in Key West. Stayed in the Eyebrow House which is operated by the folks who own Andrews Inn. The bottom half of a house, it had a great front porch with wicker chairs and a private deck in back with a jacuzzi. Conveniently located to Duvall (only one block, mid Duvall St.) yet quiet and secluded behind a fence and landscaping. The best thing about this place is it's staff. We really enjoyed getting to know KoKo and Peter. They went out of their way with grace and humor. Needless to say we would recommend this to anyone who is going to visit in Key West. There are more elegant places to stay for big bucks but for the money and location it is a clean, well kept, nicely decorated and fun place to stay.

      Peaceful haven


      We stayed at Andrews Inn for our visit to Key West, and it's what keeps us coming back again and again. The service is conscientious but not intrusive. The inn is surprisingly quiet for its location next to busy Duval Street. We could come here and only leave to eat!

      A Key West Eden


      This was our first time in Key West, and we choice Andrews Inn because it overlooked The Hemingway House and we're both cat lovers. The inn did not dissappoint us. It was a true paradise, and tucked out of the way to be truly private, yet in walking distance to nearly everything. The innkeeper was gracious and knownledgable and we're planning on going back there again soon.

      TripAdvisor Reviews Andrews Inn and Garden Cottages Key West

      4.50 of 5 stars Outstanding

      Travel Blogs from Key West

      Fast cat, low clouds, hot

      A travel blog entry by richard.boase on Feb 26, 2015

      16 photos

      ... got me to the Key West Express terminal by around 6.30am and passengers were already arriving and checking in. I was checked in by Janet who wore a name badge proudly proclaiming that she was from Yorkshire, England. I showed her my British passport for ID purposes, but she didn't react. She must process dozens of Limeys every week. The catamaran is on three levels and is pretty basic. 'Queen Elizabeth' she is not, but she was more than adequate for ...

      Key West - Last Day

      A travel blog entry by peter_ginger on Feb 09, 2014

      63 photos

      ... or so hours. We did the later. Off we went to return the bikes , which we did...but grabbed a pair from the bnb before we packed up. Packed by 8 we hit the local coffee/cafe shop for java and something for breakfast. . We then headed out for shopping and ended up in the touristy part of town. The boats were in with tourists and we were mixed in. Ginger got some ...

      Key West Odds and Ends

      A travel blog entry by dan.donnab on Jan 26, 2013

      1 comment, 9 photos

      ... walked around. There was a giant cruise ship docked there, but Dan could make out where the old submarine basin was. There were a couple of beautiful commerical hotels and a large complex labeled "Naval Administration" which, on closer inspection, was a really nice hotel. Someone in Miami had told us that the Navy operated a nice hotel in Key West for military personnel, and it sure is! And it's nice that military personnel can stay there for a reduced ...

      The Southern Tip

      A travel blog entry by mkuncio on Mar 20, 2012

      4 photos

      ... decided to go jet skiing. I had tried to go jet skiing in a few places around the world but for some reasons there was always problems with the ski’s, so I’d never actually been .We decided to go for a later time slot so it gave us a bit of time to unwind and have some lunch after driving directly from Miami.

      We headed down to the pier where we got ready to head out on the skis. We had a guide with us to take us around the ...

      When going North takes you South

      A travel blog entry by kellyday on Jun 08, 2011

      28 photos

      ... fun with them our last night in Key West that I can't help but spread the word. We ended up getting a CD from them, which we have listened to multiple times on our road trip. Good music, good guys, good times.

      We spent our last night in Florida back in Ft Lauderdale, and enjoyed more delicious wine and food with Jason's parents. Week 1 in the states was over, and we were officially on our way to starting another new adventure in the USA.